Ive heard 2 things
1. That was the original plan but Gandolf fell.
2. The eagle would not go near Modor because of the eye.
Why didn't they bring lava back from mt doom and safely destory the ring from rivendell?
Aiden Wilson
Jeremiah White
Why didn't Frodo just put the ring around his big hairy hobbit cock and tell Sauron to come and get it?
Dylan Ramirez
Why didn't Gandalf use a super speed spell on Frodo so he could run like the Flash to Mt Doom?
Andrew Clark
Why didn't they tell the Dwarves there was a mithril deposit under Mount Doom and let them dig underneath it?
Parker Collins
The eye only exists in the movies
Josiah Cook
Delet this for reminding me of the Yugo duels in LotD, I struggled
Dylan Kelly
Why didnt they just encase the ring in a ball of iron and drop it in the ocean???
Robert Harris
Why didn't they just throw it into another volcano?
Isaac Clark
That would be brilliant, the Ring wouldnt be destroyed but how the fuck would Sauron get it out?
Samuel Sullivan
Couldn't the eagles have at least taken them to gondor or somewhere else that was safe and closer to the eye than rivendell?