Punk > metal

forever and always

Attached: Ginn-Rollins.jpg (500x300, 31.99K)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/pwn_mLIJcGI
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

opbp

Metal is better than straightforward punk, but punk derivative genres like noise rock and post punk are better than metal.

As long as it's based.

Attached: FearMoreBeer.jpg (300x300, 45.55K)

My favorite stuff in both genres tends to be where the two meet - stuff like crust punk, underground metalcore, grindcore, crossover thrash, sludge metal, etc.

I like punk's idealism, lyricism, emphasis on melody and noise, and emotional expression. But I like metal's complexity, adventurousness, and imagination. Put them together and it's usually at least interesting.

Punk is dated
Metal is timeless

name a single good punk song

blitzkrieg bop

I went through a punk phase, for about all of 2 weeks before I discovered heavy metal.

I went through a metal phase, then I hit puberty.

holy based

tikes

Is that why there are still punk bands????

But what about the fact that Black Flag played metal and were GOOD at it? (Side two of My War, and The Process of Weeding Out for example)

Did a metalhead fuck some anons gf or something? What’s with all the anti metal threads all of a sudden?

Based Didametalheadfucksomeanonsgforsomething?What’swithalltheantimetalthreadsallofasudden? poster

Punk is gay as hell

Black Flag were metal

Good metal is like proggy hardcore punk. Nothing beats it

T. that little fag who got nearly raped and beat up by Rollins for accusing Black Flag of selling out and going metal

this.

poop >farts

metal is pool, punk is farts so yes.
hardcore is sharts

Yep.

Is that why punks have spent the last 30 years trying to copy metal bands? youtu.be/pwn_mLIJcGI

But the combination of the two is better than either.

essentially

/thread

both have their contradictions

metal is seemingly over complex music made by meatheads

punk is simplistic "street" music made by art students

Punk was always astro turfed crap.

yes

Punk is a completely pointless genre. It's inferior to metal in literally every way.

punk was a funny meme that lasted for 2 years in the late 70's then it became an ironically unaware parody of itself

Post punk is pretty good but most metal genres are still better than it

>and were GOOD at it

Industrial > both

>muh ABRASIVE
literal meme genre

>thinks industrial music is power electronics meme noise and nothing else
literal meme post

only if its the clash

pretty vacant
holiday in cambodia
streetwaves
rise above
sheena is a punk rocker
I wanna be your dog
rock the casbah
wardance
personality crisis
what's going on
the list goes on

It all sucks, classic industrial, industrial rock etc...
For people easily entertained by ABRASIVENESS

kek

>It all sucks, classic metal, death metal etc
>For people easily entertained by RIFFS

Nazi Punks FUCK OFF

Punk has been invaded by mu-males and soiboys unlike metal

Metal has been invaded by them though. Metalsucks and Metal Injection are run by them.

oh shut up

and realised you like men

Melodic phrases > samples of cans dropping down a flight of stairs

any hardcore punk recommendations for someone who already knows all the classics? I need more loud and fast music in my life.

Yes of course of course

I agree, punk is better than metal, but they absolutely shine when they're combined in genres like heavy hardcore, crossover thrash, powerviolence, grindcore, and crust punk.

The Germs - Lexicon Devil
Bad Brains - Sailin' On

based

Punk has shit riffs if it's not post-punk so no

>noise rock
>post punk
>good punk derivative genres

Right answer would be screamo and like three math rock albums

Post punk is great, noise rock is poop though

>punk is simplistic "street" music made by art students
Not always the case. The whole UK82 and Oi! movements in the UK were mostly made by kids from Council estates and shitty Northern towns. They stood pretty firmly in opposition to the artsy middle class bands of the post-punk and anarcho scenes. Also New York hardcore in the states was made by street trash kids who were often second gen immigrants.

>music should only be judged by it's technical aspects

>metal is seemingly over complex music made by meatheads
This is false too btw, only prog metal would fit this description