Apocrypha would have been way better if it was Jeanne Alter

Asspuller and destroyer of humanity's salvation

>removing astolfo
Fag

As much as I hate Apocrypha I actually didn't mind Astolfo that much. If he wasn't sucking Sieg's dick the entire series like every other character I think he could have been a decent character.

And she should wear the Shinjuku casual outfit all the time

Sorry to tell you user but astolfo is an awful character

She's an avenger not a ruler.

Can any gachafags confirm if JAlter is actually a more interesting character?

Attached: 68747470733a2f2f73332e616d617a6f6e6177732e636f6d2f776174747061642d6d656469612d736572766963652f53746f7279496d6167652f6a56416b6a564c586e37766664513d3d2d3633303731303638372e31353534393761323335623933306130363736303538393836323833.jpg (720x402, 51.71K)

Apocrypha would have been better if it was about the homosexual love between a retarded homunculus and a retarded paladin.

She's a tryhard edgelord. She's always mad about everything but that's just an effect of her class; Avengers have an innate skill that makes them constantly mad about everything. The thing with Jannu Alter is that she's a fake, a fraud. She was created when Gilles made a wish to the Grail to produce his ideal Jannu, one who despises the world for what it did to her. Since the true Jannu has no such hatred, a fake Jannu was produced.

The problem, however, is that Jannu Alter has no basis for her hatred. She's a fake. She was never burnt at the stake. She has no idea what it's like to be burnt alive. So while she's constantly burning with hatred by pure virtue of being an Avenger, because she has no foundation for that hatred, it's not particularly bad. She's just a delinquent with a bad temper and a childish innate hatred for the world. So more often than not, she acts more like a completely petty and irritable doofus than a dark servant of vengeance.

Apocrypha would have been way better if Evil Cat was the main servant

Attached: 1585865932742.jpg (519x980, 347.38K)

To go along with what this user said, her anger is so tied to her class alone that when she got a class change for her summer version, she's just a dorky tsundere.

Attached: 1584477188651.jpg (970x1018, 171.08K)

Is an Eviler Cat fine too?

Attached: __atalanta_and_atalanta_fate_and_2_more_drawn_by_gin_moku__sample-b868d53ff6d945eccf26208fa3a30b1d.jpg (850x1177, 208.72K)

Sieg started out living based solely on survival instinct. After being saved by Astolfo and having some talk with Chiron, he starts to wonder what he could ever do with a life as short as his.
Smash cut to having his life saved by Siegfried. Sieg now has an entire life ahead of him, but still nothing he can think of using it for.
Comedic hijinks with Jannu (they were kinda cute in volume, not yet reaching the point of forced). Talks a little bit with that farmer who lost his son.
After pondering for a while, Sieg decides that what he wants is to save his fellow homuncculi, because he feels empathy towards their situation - because he wants to do for them what nobody else would have done for hik short of literal heroes.
The plan succeeds, the homus are saved.
Past this point we can see Higashide lost interest and decided to just copy Shirou, so he sacrifices himself trying to save Astolfo, then the Fran stuff happens, yada yada.
Dream sequence with Fafnir vs Sieg, etc.

Attached: sieg.jpg (860x484, 54.08K)

Without memeing? Starts off as a completely cowardly blank-slate homunculus with nothing to him but the desperate desire to not die, then once basically fusing with Siegfried becomes a soft-spoken, reserved, polite, innocent, and good-hearted yet extremely emotional and aimless artificial human with a reckless streak due to his death wish of wanting to basically die for something to give his own life a purpose in order to honor the man who died for him who gradually becomes more mature, self-aware, and genuinely selfless as he gets influenced by and comes to understand the ideals, values, and actions of the moral paragons he encounters in the HGW (Jeanne, Siegfried, Chiron, Astolfo, Karna, and somewhat even Mordred) to the point he's willing to seal himself to protect the things they believed in even if he doesn't have the same level of faith in those things. He's no Shirou, Shiki, or even Kerry, but there is legitimate personality there and he can be pretty endearing, sort of like a dumb, quiet puppy in the LN. Anime adaption however pretty much turned him into a gaping black hole of emotion and personality who just stares into the camera until the very end. But then again anyone who read the source knows the anime fucked everyone over.

Attached: 1450908965982.jpg (311x317, 21.42K)

The only reason she's popular is because she's a jannu reskin who's a tsundere and is for (You).
Don't let any gachabrain tell you otherwise.

Attached: HorribleSubs_Houseki_no_Kuni_-_04_720p.mkv_snapshot_03.31_2017.10.29_06.38.30.jpg (1280x720, 348.03K)

Attached: 1552354304286.jpg (1020x900, 173.42K)

Attached: 1551752814798.jpg (850x899, 138.65K)

This, but also fuck Hakuno. Both series suffered from the main characters being so fucking boring

Attached: faggot.png (1597x857, 1.17M)

>and is for (You).
This whether a character is for (You) or not is all gachabrains really care about no matter how much they may pretend otherwise

Attached: 1518495036307.jpg (2894x4093, 2.76M)

Of course

Attached: 1585803721487.png (1699x2400, 2.17M)

Attached: 1512959924189.jpg (1500x1281, 328.35K)

No, she is worse

>Past this point we can see Higashide lost interest and decided to just copy Shirou, so he sacrifices himself trying to save Astolfo, then the Fran stuff happens, yada yada.
They hit similar beats but their arcs are still vastly different and this still follows the aspect of Sieg having nothing to do with his life. At the risk of sounding reductive, Shirou does what he does on pure instinct because he thinks and believes literally everyone else is more important than himself. Sieg, on the other hand is intentionally putting his life at risk for the people he cares about because he thinks that will give him the value he's looking for. In later volumes, it becomes apparent that he's personally devalued his own life to the point he's just trying to die for whatever passes as a 'higher purpose' until Jeanne and his eventual fight and ten page long talk with Karna finally snap him out of it.

When will FGO die?

As long as they keep introducing genderbent characters? Probably never.

Exactly what you'd expect from a homunculus without any sort of life experience. Apoc's crime wasn't Sieg per se, but giving him way too much focus. If he were doing his thing in the background I wouldn't have minded him so much.

Never

>garbage would have been way better if it had more garbage