Now that's all said and done, which was the bigger disaster longterm?

YOU CANT JUST MAKE LUKE HAVE A HUMAN SIDE I WANTED TO HIM EXPLODE THE ATATs WITH HIS MIND. I WANTED REY TO BE A KENOBI

I just didn't want to be bored

TLJ killed a trilogy but brought down the whole cinematic universe with it. Also, it had something to build up from, they had the perfect cash grab and managed to ruin it, in the next film they even tried to fix it by annoying the few people who liked the previous train wreck. The whole thing is a mess.

JL is shit all the way and there was much hype for it, but still they were all fairly new characters(I mean this incarnation). It's something they can simpy retcon later. It didn't ruin Batman toys sales, you know. And it's not like you had 6 fairly decent DC universe films and then fucked up at some point. It was born dead.

The DCEU was always a disappointing nonstarter of a franchise. JL didn’t ruin anything because there was nothing to ruin. BvS and SS were worse and MOS is overrated.
The sequel trilogy tainted the originals by making the OG heroes pathetic failures. So it’s far far worse.

TLJ was pure unfiltered kino that only enrages literal autists. JL on the other hand was the cinematic equivalent of premature ejaculation. Absolutely no buildup of the DCEU made it unworthy of a teamup movie. It probably killed any idea of a well connected DC movie universe for at least 15 years. So yeah, I'd say JL was the bigger fuckup.

At this stage it's still JL. Both franchises had massive potential and goodwill at their disposal, JL dashed that immediately while the full effects of TLJ are still playing out as SW sputters along. The management surrounding SW is also even worse than DC's for both of their respective franchises, making it more difficult to lay all of it on TLJ.

When is the Snydercut going to drop?

TLJ or any sequel for the matter. The story was done and any sort of continuation about the skywalkers was destined to soil a decent saga for blockbuster standards. That's what the stupid fanboys get for demanding more meat of a dead horse. Well deserved.

JL dooming the dceu was like nothing of value was lost. It was a disaster from the get go.

Rise of Skywalker made it obvious to me JJ is the problem and not Rian. Rian had to deal with JJs mystery box shit and he took the flack for it.

they can always reboot capeshit
you can't reboot Star Wars without ruining the brand even more