Who sings the Ahhhhs in A Day in the Life? Is it Paul or John?
youtu.be
Who sings the Ahhhhs in A Day in the Life? Is it Paul or John?
Luis Garcia
Other urls found in this thread:
twitter.com
youtube.com
voca.ro
twitter.com
Austin Thomas
It's obviously John. Giles Martin confirmed this. The fact that there's people who think that it's Paul is infuriating.
Brody Harris
i dont see how its john at all
Cameron Lewis
I’m pretty sure the dude who remastered Sgt. Pepper confirmed that it’s Paul
Camden Edwards
I’ve analyzed this over the years. There’s a 40% chance it’s John and a 60% chance it’s Paul mimicking John’s voice
Leo Allen
because it sounds exactly like john
no, he confirmed it was john
twitter.com
Anthony Roberts
This is certainly Paul. You can even hear him inhale right after he finishes dream to prep for the ahhhhs
Angel Davis
>I’ve analyzed this over the years. There’s a 40% chance it’s John and a 60% chance it’s Paul mimicking John’s voice
This is what I'm inclined to believe. Only starting reading this debate about a month ago and that's the answer I've come up with. Could be George, I always thought Taxman was just John and Paul singing together.
Carter Price
I was just thinking about this in my car 2 hours ago. I always thought it was John but recently entertained the idea that it was Paul and eventually came back to thinking it's John.
Aaron Perez
Giles Martin doesn't know shit about music. If you listened to the new remixes you'd know this.
Christian Bell
Fuck. All my life I thought it was John but it's clearly Paul. I don't know how to feel about this
Logan Rodriguez
John definitely.
Ayden Lewis
Actually I just relistened to the song with the vocal turned up and now I think it's actually Paul. The voice seems too clear in that high of a range to be John, unless it's been compressed heavily or the track is turned up way up. No, now I'm listening to it again and it sounds like it could be John. Goddamnit. It definitely sounds like the kind of melody Paul would sing, but the tone so subtly sounds like John's while STILL sounding like Paul's
Xavier Powell
geoff emerick, their engineer also confirmed it to be john.
he's preparing for the high "oooohs" not the "ahhhhs"
it's john, you idiots
Jaxson Cox
>It's Paul per Sam Okell the guy who did most of the physical re-mixing of Sgt Pepper for the 50th Anniversary Edition. See Sound on Sound Magazine August 2017 Edition in an interview with Sam and Giles where Sam explains in detail about the 4 tracks of Paul's vocal, specifically the 4th vocal track which contains the Aahs and shows the "Aah" vocal delay track below it. There are also photos of the Pro Tools mixing screen showing the whole mix session so you can see the 4 tracks and vocal delay track he's talking about if you enlarge it.
>"“Paul’s main vocal track is in stereo, because we gave it some spread with the Waves S1 Stereo Imaging plug-in, so it has a different sound than John’s lead. We also split off two little bits to be able to pan them left and right. His fourth vocal track is the ‘aaah’ section, and below it is an ‘Aah delay’ aux track. "
Source: YouTube comments
Robert Kelly
It's clearly John, with Paul wooing in the background
William Anderson
>"Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh, ahhhhhhhhhhhhh,ahhhhhhhhhhh"
Yep, another granny moment from Paul
Juan Gomez
its john you idiots
Jonathan Butler
How the fuck is this a debate it is obv john
Dylan Russell
That's what I was thinking
Camden Myers
Why are faggots pretending it’s anyone but John?
Adrian Sanchez
Because it’s Paul’s section so why would John be on it? Also the melody is almost 100% a Paul melody.
Xavier Cook
doesn't sound like john at all
Ayden Ward
I was at the studio sessions and can confirm it's Pete Best
Brandon Cruz
Lennon had the better voice and authored the most iconic moments of their catalog, cope
Eli Richardson
fucking retards it's obviously thom singing that part
Sebastian Moore
I sang that part
AMA
Brandon Hughes
Are you John or Paul?
Alexander Parker
Neither
Ryan Reed
based Pete
Evan Parker
i covered the beatles