So, is this his best album?

So, is this his best album?

Attached: NIN_TF_(V).jpg (600x599, 63.29K)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=laFCqCCEGTc
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

nah

precisely

Yeah.

1. The Fragile
2. The Downward Spiral
3. Year Zero
4. Broken
5. Hesitation Marks

So when this came out Pitchfork gave it 2.0
Then when the reissue came out they had another guy review it and he gave it a 8.7.

The fact that Pitchfork gave this a 2 makes me like it more

Because in 1999 it wasn't cool to like Trent because he was a drug-addled edgy rockstar. Then in the 2000s he became a sober "art rock" musician with indie credibility so Pitchfork revised their opinions on him like the fucking posers they are.

tds is better, although the fragile is great too

TDS is overrated. i personally think their later stuff is better, The Fragile, Year Zero, Still, The Slip, & The Trilogy Are better than The Downward Spiral In My Opinion

>The Slip
>better than TDS
Nigga what?

Attached: 1528257610261.png (1200x1042, 246.69K)

The Slip is a great album, only plebs disagree

It's nice, but fucking garage rock Trent is not better than the masterpiece that is TDS, I'm not having that.

tds isn’t my favourite nin’s album, but i still think it’s the best one. it’s very emotional, “honest” and it’s conceptual. also i think that many later stuff is quite similar while tds is kinda unique.

The Fragile > Still > Year Zero > TDS > Trilogy > Ghosts V-VI > Broken > PHM > Ghosts I-IV > The Slip > With Teeth > HM

tds is better than still and year zero, it’s obvious. broken shouldn’t be rated so low, it’s a really good ep. and with teeth is better than phm

Why does nobody like pretty hate machine?

i think it's the most dated out of all the stuff he's done.

Attached: trent.jpg (800x450, 31K)

idk but i just love this album less and less, mostly because of the lyrics, i mean all this
>noooooo she left meeeee

It's his most immature work, It sounds like something i would listen to at 16. It's the normie choice and doesn't come anywhere near TDS, Fragile, Year zero ETC.

Half of it is really fucking good and half of it is completely forgettable.

that checks out

Because it's his most derivative and immature work. It sounds like exactly you'd expect, a depressed 24 year old trying to sound like Skinny Puppy, Depeche Mode and Ministry.

To me, quintessential NIN is PHM, TDS and TF.
For an on-topic answer, objectively speaking TF is his best work though subjectively I think TDS is better.

cuz they;re faggot

>Lay my hands on heaven and the sun and the moon and the stars
>While the devil wants to fuck me in the back of his car
Nah, it's the PHM lovers who are the faggots.

youtube.com/watch?v=laFCqCCEGTc

PHM is the best and no one can tell me otherwise. Head like a Hole and Terrible Lie go harder than anything else he’s ever written, except for Broken, which is a little too short but also good.

yes

Attached: start with the fragile.jpg (1500x2000, 206.98K)

terrible lie>head like a hole>sin>down in it>that’s what i get>the only time>kinda i want to>ringfinger>something i can never have>sanctified

The Downward Spiral > The Fragile > Still > Year Zero > The Trilogy > Ghosts I-VI > Broken > The Slip >>> Hesitation Marks >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Pretty Hate Machine

pls stop rating broken that low

FUCK Forgot With Teeth, so just imagin it's between Trilogy And Ghost

i know i was just fucking with you broken is my Third favorite next to The Fragile, But everything else is acurate

It's better than anything Al Jourgensen ever made.

Accurate*

Broken is a mediocre proto-The Downward Spiral. It was a much needed stepping stone to lead the way for it, but it sounds even more painfully dated than PHM.

it’s my most favourite nin’s album(ep, but doesn’t matter), then tds and then the fragile

but in fact, trent found that new tds sound that was much heavier than phm on broken. and phm is still worse