>Noise
>Ambient
>experimental
ITT: Genres that shouldn't class as music
Kayden Turner
Juan Morgan
experimental can be anything, you gotta give that a pass
noise gets a pass only as a part of something - noise rock, industrial
agree with ambient wholeheartedly
also
>trap
Isaiah Hall
>drone
>avant garde
>spoken word
Benjamin Cook
Musique concrète, field recordings, spoken word, noise
Liam Jones
>anatolian rock
Bentley Reyes
Rap
Anthony Garcia
Filtered
Dominic Walker
Whatever, it isn't music.
Nathan Collins
>NOOO YOU CANT NOT LIKE SHITTY THIRD RATE "MUSIC"!!!
>FILTERED!!!
Henry Ross
rap, country, heavy metal, classic rock
Colton Howard
OMG MY 3 FAVORITE GENRES
Dylan Nguyen
Imagine being filtered by ambient.
Luis Rodriguez
Why does the distinction between non-music and music even matter
Adrian Cook
if what you say is true OP, then music fucking sucks
Nolan Cook
"Emo-Pop"
Alexander Lewis
Music = harmony + melody + rhythm
If you can't connect the dots without them being spelled out to you in 4/4 major scale triads then you're fucking retarded
Adrian Jones
>pop
>
Dylan Green
>Music = harmony + melody + rhythm
Concrete music and field recordings don't have those.
Owen Ortiz
rap
Caleb Perry
art doesn't mean anything specific by definition. music doesn't mean anything specific by definition. everything is art and everything is music. get with it
Logan Nguyen
Both musique concrete and field recordings either have
A. Disjoint rhythm produced from the nature of recording
B. A single rhythm, essentially one very long whole note
Both are perfectly valid explorations of the medium, having one solid rhythm is compositionally not very different from just repeating a short rhythm over and over
Luke Taylor
/Thread
William Adams
is Scat porn art?
Zachary Murphy
Imagine being so insecure in your inability to enjoy unconventional music that you make a whole thread crying about it
Logan Garcia
So literally all noise is music. Gotcha.
Hunter Nguyen
>Imagine being so insecure in your inability to enjoy unconventional music that you make a whole thread crying about it
>imagine being even more insecure to the point where you reply to said thread
Cooper Young
If it reflects a state of being, and elicits a response from it's consumers, why would it not be?
Nicholas Wood
Why are there categories for anything? Everything is just atoms.
Jose Gomez
Non argument. Merzbow has established both critical and popular acclaim making literal noise, and the validity of the art form is even more evidenced by the fact that his most popular albums are also his shittiest and most basic, same as within every other genre
Jason Gutierrez
Edgy
Jayden Hall
What the fuck are you even saying? The fact is that if field recordings and spoken word are music, then everything we hear is music. We're all listening to music 24/7.