What does Yas Forums consider to be an "Ok" rating on the 5-star scale? What would be a good/bad rating? When should an album be rated 5 stars?
I'm asking this because I'm new to rym and I feel like my ratings are affected by thinking that 4 stars = 70/100 = Average score. Help me rate stuff better Yas Forums.
It's up to you. I use a logarithmic scale, which means the difference between 4 and 5 stars is very little but the difference between 1 and 2 stars is very big. It lets me rank the albums I like more precisely, a 1.5 star is "ok" for me.
Henry Garcia
2.5 is ok
Chase Barnes
Great = 5 good = 4.5 Ok = 4 Meh = 3.5 Bad = 3 Awful = 2.5
Asher Ramirez
>4 stars = 70/100 What? Are you retarded?
4 Stars / 5 Stars = 4/5 = 8/10 = 80/100
The most average rating is 2.5 stars = 50/100
4 stars is a very good score, 3.5 (70/100) is also good.
Mason Rivera
This is a pretty accurate description of what I've been using, but I feel like there's too much of the scale I'm not using. However, I also may just be listening to albums that I have a predisposition to liking, making my scoring higher than average.
Jayden Campbell
For me it's 0 = Mediocre 0.5 = Competent 1 = Ok 1.5 = Average 2 = Good 2.5 = Very Good 3 = Very Very Good 3.5 = Great 4 = Very Great 4.5 = Fantastic 5 = Incredible
Sebastian Edwards
I have never seen a more retarded rating system, holy shit
Connor Nguyen
>taking the obvious bait
Connor Bell
4 stars is 80% (if your rating is supposed to mean overall quality compared to every other piece of music) which statistically means it should be better than 80% of what you review. Therefore, statistically you could only hand out 4/5 20% of the time. Of course where it falls apart is the statistics don't represent the reality of the situation and you could never give a perfect score because quality wise it would have to be 'better' than everything else you've reviewed. You just have to 'feel it out' which is bs.
Ryan Lopez
What's wrong with it? I don't bother rating or reviewing music I strongly dislike. Saves me time.
John Gomez
0 = Completely terrible 0.5 = awful 1 = pretty bad 1.5 = bad 2 = poor, not that good 2.5 = mediocre 3 = good 3.5 = very good 4 = awesome 4.5 = masterpiece 5 = perfection
0.5 - Awful/Terrible 1 - Bad 1.5 - Poor 2.0 - Below Average 2.5 - Average 3.0 - Decent 3.5 - Good 4.0 - Excellent 4.5 - Near Perfection 5.0 - Personal Favorite/Perfect
Ayden Campbell
For my own internal library:
0 - unrated (this is the default iTunes star rating) 1 - garbage, delete 2 - can't decide if I keep or delete, next time I hear it I have to set to 1 or 3 3 - good song, keep it (at around 10k songs) 4 - great song (2k-3k songs) 5 - amazing song (500 songs, give or take)