Post what you're looking for in feedback. Be specific if possible. GIVE feedback to GET feedback.
Post WIP's on Clyp.it or Vocaroo
DO NOT link to Soundclouds, Bandcamp, or YouTube etc- there are dedicated threads for posting them and anything resembling self promotion will result in bad feedback.
He looks like he just noticed "Laura's" disgusting scent
Caleb Scott
What are some quick tips on mixing guitar with drums?
Brayden Thompson
how do I get older anjunabeats/anjunadeep sound? or older edm progressive house sound? like pre 2012 vibes/sound inb4 vengeance
Daniel Fisher
reminder to always be a solo act and only collaborate with others as separate artists can you imagine if the guy you're committed to with your whole career comes out as trans? if you leave everyone will think it's because of his coming out and if you don't you'll be laughed at forever theres no winning with this shit
tried to work on this breakcorish machinegirl inspired type thing. not usually making this type of music though so any feedback helps. thoughts on the oversaturation? ending is a bit of a mess still
sounds really good to me. that sound that comes in at like 1:08 is sick as hell but could definitely use some slight variance through out the track so it doesn't get too stale
Matthew Gutierrez
Yo there were some parts that were jammin, the almost emo vocal from the mid point threw me off. I don’t usually listen to this sort of thing but some of the sampling was interesting and dope. Since there’s so much different shit going on in the track it’s hard to say if the parts I didn’t like overshadowed the track as a whole
I take it the saturation is on purpose so I won’t comment but I think it sounds a little “dead” like it could use more highs. The bass was a tad low for my taste.
I’m the guy above you so feed for feed? ;)
Elijah James
Yo thank you yeah I might vary it up a little. I’m going for a more minimal thing so it’s hard to draw the line. Thanks again for listening
Jacob Price
i like it, but if it was my track and i was listening to it to find what to go and change first, this is what stood out: hats and ride from 2:20 are too high in the mix and too central at 3:40 i don't like how the kick and bass interact, i would guess the s/c or volume env on the bass is real sharp, no groove to the interaction arrangement wise i would say that not enough happens to the bass with it being so central to the track that it could be played for a long time in a dj mix. it is too repetitive without action. but i like it. if i heard a short sample on beatport on whatever, i would definitely check it out. i would ask, what is the central theme of the track and where does the energy come from?
Jaxson Hall
the kickdrum is a little stuffy and it doesn't have much of a soundstage (?) but the rest seems alright to me if a little repetitive keep going
the mix sounds a little neutered of attack and dynamic range but i like the song, neat sounds and samples
Jonathan Howard
Who are the most talented ghost producers? Who has the best portfolio?
Evan Phillips
in the main part of the track i think there is too much going on and the sounds overlap. i guess this is the style of the genre to have lots of samples, but there is overlap of sounds and it makes it difficult to hear what the actual sounds are. it's an interesting track, but i would say it needs to be cleaner. there's not much at the top or the bottom
Adrian Robinson
yeah those emoish vocals might get scrapped then. using abletons saturator so could probably do better with something else. struggling like hell getting the bass right but definitely noted.
what i said here basically. definitely sounds dope minimal but like just an ever so slightly moving filter or something on that sound so it doesnt hit the exact same every time is all i mean. that bass is incredible tho. what vst you using?
Aaron Foster
Thanks for the detailed feedback I’ll go in tomorrow and see what I can whip up as far as spicing up the bass. I really appreciate it, thanks again!
Deeper kick you think? I’ll flip through some samples tomorrow or I might just try and nerd out and synthesize a kick that fits better. Thanks for the feedback
That’s a Bass Bot v2 (303 clone). It works nicely with midi which is why I like it because besides pressing random pattern I dont understand the interface at all. I just programmed the pattern in ableton and then I ran that into a tape distortion with some lightish chorus
Sebastian Cooper
hmm i spent a bunch of time trying to have things fade around and stuff only to kill it all with the saturation. think you got a point
Gabriel Thompson
Either pressing play on a whole track or pressing play on pieces of tracks and then twiddling effects
Isaac Lopez
can /prod/ tell me what Nicolas Jaar is doing on his laptop this whole set?
I don’t have to watch to know that is basically the extent of a laptop set. It’s like in between DJing and performing with hardware/controllers and actually programming live. There’s no realistic way he’s doing anything else with just a laptop unless he has super autism and can manipulate a bunch of shit with just a trackpad
Noah Williams
After casually glancing at the video MAYBE he’s also doing some live granular synth stuff which is pretty simple as far as only using a trackpad.
Eli Thomas
This sounds more like an excerpt from a movie soundtrack, however I'm wondering if there's some way I could turn it in to an actual song, any tips are welcome :) clyp.it/fzrzamkc
Gavin Howard
>MAYBE he’s also doing some live granular synth stuff which is pretty simple as far as only using a trackpad. any examples of this? just want to picture how it's being manipulated, etc.
Jose Torres
Last day analog dreams is free. Have another other soft synths gone free for corona?
Liam Collins
can i use this without whatever the fuck native instruments is? because it didn't let me pick which drive to install it to so i'm already pretty close to uninstalling
Elijah Foster
I'm not improving one bit and I don't know why. I want to improve my keyboard playing but don't really know how.
Brody Bell
how to improve at anything: challenge yourself to do something slightly above your skill level- not so much that it's overwhelming and unfun but enough that you're working harder than you usually do
Grayson Perry
>the world is on lockdown >almost no scene releases Are those cracking teams salaried? Do they all work at an office or something?
Julian Perry
i'm new to recording myself and i'm trying to make some noise rock. i don't want it to sound polished or anything, and in fact i'd like to lean into a sort of shitty sound. i know most of what goes into a good sound comes from good recording rather than mixing but the reality is i gotta sing in the car and i don't have good equipment lol. but regardless, i know i can't just record and then be done, even if i want it to sound "unpolished." i'm trying to use my ear but i can't tell if for example the vocals are too loud or if there's a question i can't even begin to ask. i appreciate whatever advice you got clyp.it/fkkfqre5
i'm not really looking for help on the music itself, i know it isn't really too interesting (that is, it's dogshit). just trying to learn mixing stuff
Aiden Lee
Why can I only make soulless unfinished EDM demos? What is wrong with me? vocaroo.com/hJFhbyo57zY
Do you just trial and error your way to melodies and chords?
Christian Diaz
iMac Late 2015 Core i5 2.8GHZ yes or no to run Ableton Live 10?
How shitty is it to have lack of portability?
Henry Gutierrez
what are the problems you're having? these two instruments go super well with each other and pretty much don't clash at all, so be more specific
Joseph Moore
Where do you find images to use as covers for tracks? I'm looking for lo-fi strange/weird/uncomfortable pictures with david lynch aesthetics. Stuff like pic related would also work
this shit turned out so garbage i barely bothered to arranged it might be one of the worst things ive ever made just complete uninspired garbage but practice, right? i guess
>You are gifted. I'd cut my left thump and swallow it if I had half your fucking talent. I guess you can make a hit my just resting your butt on a keyboard while recording it and then throwing 4 effects and a cats meowing over it. im so incredibly sorry you feel that way because im only okay at best. this is only my third year doing this shit though so if you think im good it wont be long till youre at my level.
Of all the free soft synths which ones have the most tutorials? I found the helm interface easiest to get my head around, is that a good one to start with? Any other suggestions? I need something to make a bass line to play a long with my guitar to.
Wyatt Barnes
synth1 probably
Ethan Sanchez
bump
Sebastian Price
any good programs/plug ins for voice manipulation? stuff like autotune, pitched up, etc.
really new to this stuff
Owen King
I usually pick a scale, decide if I want the overall cadence(dunno if that’s the right word) to go up or down and then just experiment with chords.
For melodies they “just come to me” I guess, once you have your chords it’s easier.
Jordan Ramirez
70s japanese tv
Bentley Hernandez
Weird question and I hope someone can help me out here: Playboi Carti - No Time has a mixing glitch at 2:01. How does something like this happen? Could I replicate it myself, in a regular DAW? How? Would greatly appreciate any insight.
seems a little fast try turn down the tempo a bit I feel like the hats could get busier with like rolls and stuff Maybe be the snare could be wetter I feel like the bass could be dirtier What if you did a section that changed it up somehow like it went halftime or it used a synth bass or something Overall I fwi, the 808 pattern especially knocks. Would love to hear future versions
Daniel Adams
RAM and hard drive/ssd space? Regardless, a modern computer can run abelton, now depends how intensive you are, plug-ins, how big usually are your projects etc... Portability simply depends on your lifestyle and if you intend to play live. Do you have another computer/laptop? Only you know that info.
Leo Sanders
clyp.it/4a442hnz is it catchy how do i make it catchy if it isn't?
Jeremiah Powell
I consider buying a mic. Either Shure SM57LC oder MXL 770 - any recommendations/experiences? Want to use it for vocals/voice, instruments and recording of sounds for effects/samples.
Ayden Bennett
sounds like a fuckup during exporting or en/transcoding to the final medium these happen all the time because computers are just like that and stuff like that should be found by quality control, somebody probably got fired there if you want to replicate it take your final render and cut a straight up hole of 1-5ish samples of silence, no fades just a plain gap
Anthony Flores
the quality of your room as in acoustics and freedom of noise from streets, computer fans, neighbours and all that dictates the choice inbetween a condenser or a dynamic mic with the dynamic mic it's easier to get rid of most of the room influence just by getting up close, the condenser will probably sound "better" as in more hifi without needing the same amount of polish, but it will pick up a lot more shit you might not want doesn't mean you can't add a shittonne of gain to a dynamic and use that with more distance to get a roomier sound or you get super close to a condenser to drown out the surrounding in a similar way when shelving the proximity effect the fuck down but that's just the basic gist
Chase Edwards
I have this complex bass line on midi, is there a way to make it sound more like the instrument without having to buy a bass? So it sounds less robotic and more fluid Like chaining the notes, if that makes any sense
Joseph Cruz
Thanks, that answers it for me. Shure for sure bcs until I got my accustics done will take some time. There's not much street noise and shit since living in a remote area but the room ...
Nicholas Smith
the intro is catchy, but feels a little too typically-melodic, like the phrase needs to end more atonally or something the rest is the opposite, not enough melody or theme or cool instrumentation, and too saturated with noises in the mids i think? it sounds like it's about to drop into a really wide mix of melodic synth and a sick bassline but it doesn't pay off what you're doing isn't the kind of music i like anyway so some of this might just be down to personal taste, also i'm a huge noob
Juan Johnson
are you using some sort of bass guitar plugin or are you fine using a synth sound? if the latter is the case you can make some amazing funky fingerstyle bass sounding shit with most simple substractive synths that's perfect for busy lines youtube.com/watch?v=Ng0iXDW2t50 here's a pretty in-depth tutorial from that guy youtube.com/watch?v=kEmt6iCaUuc
Isaiah Parker
Sweet, thanks so much. As a followup, do you think there's anything about that song that would have made that exporting/encoding error more likely? Is it something to do with the mix maybe?