Be a whore

not any worse than "here, take this piece of your progenitor we carved for 10000 years and procreate! if you won't use it you will all die!"

AND THEN CAWL TURNED HIMSELF INTO A PICKLE!
FUNNIEST SHIT ON ALL OF THE MARS

of course, what else does it look like?

If you're describing primaris marines I honestly don't really get all the complaints about them. Cawl himself is kind of poorly written though.

Not any worse than bringing back Roberta girlyman. The best part about 40k is that it was a stagnant universe where every race had a win condition (humans:emperor revives, orks: boss big enough to lead a giant wagh, necron: all tombs open, tyranids: time , eldar: I fucking forget, Tau: none because they're beta bitches) but no race had any progress on that win condition. Bringing back guilliman moves humans further ahead than the other races and is dumb

Also it's stupid how it fucks up the imperial cult which I think adds so much to the human lore

Why did they make Dawn of War 3 so garbage bros

modifying geneseed is HERESY
telling everyone that emperor told you to do it and have not a soul alive to prove it is HERESY
having a girlyman to stand in and say that he allows that is DOUBLE HERESY ON BOTH OF THEM
having girlyman secretly be in on it all along and specifically tasking you to do it without consulkting the emperor is a reason for exterminatus on both terra and mars would they not be terra and mars

>Not any worse than bringing back Roberta girlyman.
Guilliman is one of the only good primarchs though. He's an actual character in a setting full of caricatures.

>The best part about 40k is that it was a stagnant universe
Nah, that sucked. Moving the timeline ahead is excellent.

>Bringing back guilliman moves humans further ahead than the other races
The setting has, all the way back to RT era, been about humanity and the Imperium. It's not supposed to be balanced. The Imperium rules the galaxy, the other factions are all nipping at mankind's heels.

>Also it's stupid how it fucks up the imperial cult which I think adds so much to the human lore
It does not. Guilliman himself may dislike the Cult but has found himself unable to really come up with a way to get rid of it that wouldn't compromise the Imperium so he has learned to live with it. Not unlike Napoleon's relationship with Catholicism.

Cluster B-elongs in the fucking ground

they literally had vulcan dissapear to do what cawl is now doing, and it wouldn't even be heresy, because vulcan had been specifically cleared by the emperor to do all of that and its on the imperial records
nobody is fucking interested in what cpt smurf is doing