Water and ice are two different elements

>being pendantic
then fire shouldn't be an element either. why would you single out water

playing divinity original sin 2 rn. ice>water ice≠water

Attached: DOS2really.jpg (1280x720, 189.13K)

The thing is that lightning is from the domain of the sky AKA the air. The god of the sky is Zeus who used lightning.

You're right fire is just observable exothermic reaction, not an element

There was an old RTS called Theocracy that was about the aztecs, and the magic in the game was separated into
>Nature
>Sun
>Spirit
>Stars
>Moon

>He doesn't have Lightning under the Wind Element
>He doesn't have Ice under the Water element
It's like you can't even design a game

>ice is opposing element to fire, but water isn't
thank you FFX

Pretty sure the word element was used before people actually knew about atoms and molecules so nothing on the PSE is an element.

Attached: spedepasanen.jpg (600x683, 33.05K)

I mean at least that's following a theme
Mana has
>Earth, Wind, Fire, Water
Okay yeah sure
>Wood and Moon
Why though
I mean vaguely the last two seem to be Life and Death but it's still mostly just plants for Wood and arbitrary stuff like Werewolves for Moon

What if there was a game where you can shoot pure oxygen or pure hydrogen and stuff. Would it work?

>N-NO YOU CAN'T JUST CLAIM WATER ISN'T AN ELEMENT
>ICE AND WATER SHOULDN'T BE SEPARATE ELEMENTS
which is it fag

nice reading comprehension

+ WATER

Keep it simple, baby

Attached: 87b2791d4960dc5af2b8aacde14d0c71.png (596x606, 562.96K)

More like
>Moon is an Element
>Sun isn't

brainlet

Lightning is associated with storms, so I take it.

Because calling an element Ice sounds much better than calling it Cold

>Persona has a Nuke element

Attached: oak.gif (335x335, 76.83K)

Wood and earth arent the same thing at all. Ice is literally water

Magic is like a programming language, when you cast a spell you have to specify exactly what you want. The only real difference between a water spell and an ice spell is one line in the incantation that determines the temperature of the water you're conjuring into existence. Without that, the water would be conjured at a random temperature, meaning you might try to freeze your enemy to death and end up giving them a nice shvitz instead.

Here's your (You)

>first spell given is fire element
>MC's primary element is fire

Attached: zzzzzzzzzzzz.jpg (600x400, 31.51K)

>Explosion is an element

>Lightning is Fire+Wind at the same time
>Ice is Wind+Water at the same time
>Wood is Earth+Water at the same time
>Magma is Fire+Earth at the same time
>All of the properties are still treated individually
Tales of Vesperia was weird

Attached: hmm.jpg (225x225, 6.67K)

Doesn' t Grandia 1 do the same?

>Ice is Wind+Water at the same time
What in the goddamn hell?