"AMY HENNIG WAS AN AMAZING WRITER, ND WENT TO SHIT AFTER SHE LEFT!"

>"AMY HENNIG WAS AN AMAZING WRITER, ND WENT TO SHIT AFTER SHE LEFT!"
>uncharted 1-3 have mediocre writing at best

Attached: image_400x400.jpg (400x400, 29.31K)

Alternative question. How was the writing on TLOU so good when Druckmann's Uncharted 4 script was fucking garbage compared to Amy's and TLOU 2 is even worse?

Uncharted 4 had the best story. The characters actually had development and it didn't repeat the exact same beats that Hennig kept regurgitating

She also worked on jak 3 which had a weak story

Legacy of Kain, zoomer.

I have a bias towards Jak but it definitely felt like they were struggling to think of a good narrative. It's like the came up with the Dark Makers, but decided they needed one central antagonist so they just brought back Erol for the fuck of it. Odd, because Gol and Maia would've been much better choices

>game completed unrelated to Naughty Dog

t. Cuckman

Nice argument!

It's funny cause you can swap around the script the of the first 2 games, change the names around and you still would end up with the same story.

Hennig was only ever worth a shit when she was working on Legacy of Kain.

>Game written by Amy Hennig
>Doesn't count because it wasn't the same developer
>When you're concerned with the quality of the writer
Mongoloid

Because I guarantee you straley and Druck paid amy to consultate uncredited

Are we talking about Amy or Naughty Dog here? Because she is related to Legacy of Kain.

Yeah, and? Retard.

I've been wondering this myself. Did Druckmann use someone else's script for TLOU?

BASED RETARD

Attached: 1562082126478.png (540x447, 34.94K)

>when people praised that pratchett hoe for doing the writing for nu-raider
lmfao

she's been a co-something in everything she's worked on. faulting her for fuck ups is ridiculous

Attached: works.png (1038x695, 101.31K)

Gotta agree. I don't think I like anything else she's written outside LoK.

>LOL Naughty Dog Shills out in force
Dude it's over for you guys your game is gonna be DOA HAHAHAH

Attached: images (7).jpg (159x250, 6.37K)

>WE-WE MADE IT BAD ON PURPOSE!
>IF WE MAKE WHAT YOU LIEK WE FAILED!
LOL @ ND

Thing is, Uncharted script was self aware that it is just a fun Indiana Jones tribute, with supernatural stuff, cliches, cool characters, comic book villains
Uncharted 4 is pretentious shit filled with flashbacks, le unreliable narrator flashbacks, blueballing supernatural plot twist, etc

>people complain about her leaving naughty dog as if she was a huge asset
>her only good work wasn't with naughty dog

1 and 2 were legitimately entertaining action movie schlock with charming characters and dialogue. 3 was fucking terrible though, I'll give you that. Thankfully it was so bad I completely gave up on ND all together and was able to avoid all this faggotry after it.

Hello Druckmann

hi neil

Attached: 1571900961880.gif (320x240, 2.15M)

You can do the same with 3. Hell, 3's last third was beat-for-beat the same as 2's
>it was intentionally mediocre!

>simple bad

only blood omen 1 had good writing

You already stabbed her in the back to gain power in Naughty Dog. Now you make a thread to shit on her? Not cool Neil. You're an overrated hack and you always will be.

Reminder that originally Nate was suppose to have a son so he can bring him up as the father he never had, but that wasnt progressive enough. Neal had the audacity to call a QA sexist for questioning this

Attached: IMG_20200428_174819.png (713x467, 107.35K)

the only one she didn't write was BO2 and well, we all know that one is the red-headed step child of the series

>How was the writing on TLOU so good
It wasn't

>mediocre writing
it's all anyone really asks for in a video game, instead we have insultingly bad writing telling the fans to fuck themselves

>repetitive with no progression between games bad
Yes

>"Oh look, if I mock Amy Hennig, I will distract everyone from criticizing current Naughty Dog's controversies."
At least you tried

Yeah fair

UH OH LOOKS LIKE THE TRANNY IS ABOUT TO COMMIT 41%

Attached: toppest keks.jpg (410x468, 61.01K)

NO YOU DONT GET IT THE QUIPS ARE THE BEST IN THE INDUSTRY

>amy defence squad can't come up with a single counterpoint

Attached: 1564681688985.jpg (485x480, 28.23K)

iirc Druckmann wasn't the sole writer for the first one. TLoU2 had him having complete control over the story and direction of the game.

Stay salty tranny lover. She is best known for the jawless blue chad not some shitty Naughty Dog game.

Attached: 85234e627a0f1bef6006aa146966762d.jpg (300x396, 42.27K)

The setting and the background was good, the actual story beats were terrible. Chances are that the basic beats of the zombie apocalypse setting and the escort mission was designed under Hennig, and then Druckmann was the one who fleshed out the characters.

He took the road and put it in vidya format. For the second one he only used his own intimation.

So why do people keep acting like she was the best thing about ND?

Neil is a much better writer overall. Amy is better at writing jokes and that's it, but even then he makes up for it by being good at directing his actions and not hand holding them too much, so the actors can show their charisma that way.

Uncharted 1 and 2 had just enough story to drive you from set piece to set piece and go ham Indiana Jonesing it up. That's all you need.

3 was shit, but it was also the first time ND split up their staff and put them on 2 games at once. Doing so had an obvious effect on UC3's quality.