Filter or garbage?
Filter or garbage?
Landon Ramirez
Andrew Scott
Kino
Adam Gutierrez
Very good but overshadowed by its predecessors
Austin Wood
Amazing story and spooks, but the gameplay is fucking horrendous and almost ruins everything.
Jackson Hernandez
Well, at least it's better than SH3 in certain aspects.
Robert James
kino of the highest order
Jason King
This. Overshadowed, but also may have released on the tail end of that genre's golden era. Was a year later RE4 became the new model of success.
It's not garbage but the new contrarian thing is to pretend it's the best in the series. 1, 2, and 3 are on another level.
Matthew Jenkins
>amazing story
lol
Cooper Adams
Both. It's basically the mgs v of the series, unfinished and rushed out, but the story is actually good.
Angel Evans
Sorry, meant EXCEPT the story is actually good, unlike mgs v. But this was one of the earlier victims of Konami and their bullshit (don't know if kojima was in charge at this point)
Nathan Evans
I think it stands as the most interesting game in the franchise. Flawed but it was very original and it does some things really great like the apartment. Lots of people propably got filtered by the ghosts and limited inventory. It needed alot more development time, it really shows but its a great game.
Dominic Hill
50/50. As a package it's not all there but it at least tries to be more of a survival horror than the others.
Andrew Green
the invincible ghosts scared the shit out of me as a kid
Hunter Bennett
>not even a SH game during most of development
into the trash
Evan Perez
Are you talking about SH1 or SH3?
Noah Walker
Neither. It was a rushed game that had a ton of cool ideas but needed more time for them to be fully realized.
Josiah Taylor
Why does this meme keep getting spouted? This isn't true, it was always a silent Hill game.
Carter Miller
such as?
Isaac Jones
Twin Perfect
Ethan Bell
Should have been entirely in first person.
Connor Ramirez
Massive pleb filter, very interesting and experimental. A lot of things people complain about are clearly by design, and are actually good, but the basic gameplay is way worse than its predecessors for some reason. Right up there with 2 in terms of story and probably would've been the best in the series if it had an extra year of dev time.
Julian Brown
NO IT WASN'T NO IT'S NOT
FUCKING NEWFAGS NECK YOURSELVES WITH YOUR GAY LITshut the fuck upTLE GAME
Parker Williams
Are you ok?
Tyler Cook
I like the premise but as soon as I clear the first level after the "tunnel" and end up in that rain area my interest always falls flat. Hear it turns into an escort mission later that must suck.
Alexander Sullivan
Those earlier Silent Hill renderings are on a different level.
Hunter Ward
The story and the spooks. SH3 has better gameplay, leveldesign and a subjectively better protagonist but in my eyes Heather is just different not necessarily better.
David Parker
You should keep going, the first level is by far the worst in the game. The escort mission isn't NEARLY as bad as everyone says, she cant die, and you can just shut her in a safe room, do the whole area, then come back for her and leave.
Xavier Gray
Just attack whatever she attacks. That's all there is to it. Give her the strongest weapon you have and curbstomp enemies that you attack together. This includes the main antagonist. He will need a breather which will allow you to escape.
Juan Peterson
Please play it, but be aware that this game was rushed out and it shows. (devs wanted way more time because they loved working on it)
You'll see A LOT of amazing concepts and ideas, some the best in the series, but feel sad when you realize there isn't more to them due to the game being pushed out too quickly. Compared to all of the previous games, this one makes you think harder about the backstories of the characters you encounter.
Isaiah Cook
>not having an open world formula like SH1,2 and Origins
Gabriel Perez
It was the first SH I played, so it has a special place in my mind. I loved some very obscure details. The phone that keeps ringing in the apartment, the giant head that keeps staring at you, the paintings of neighbours.
However, some sections are pure trash