These are the top 6 vidya of all time, according to metacritic, do you agree?

based

>OOT
fair
>THPS2
i wouldn't go that far, but i'm not offended
>GTAIV
nope
>Soul Calibur I
fair
>Mario Galaxy
haven't played. I'm old so I'd say SM64 or 3 if any mario on list at all
>Mario Galaxy 2
two marios on same list? the fuck? No.

>iv
>better than sa
>better than vc
>better than bully

in terms of a crime sandbox
>maybe
>yes
>yes

in terms of story
>no
>no
>yes

Galaxy 2 doesn't deserve to be on there.
That game watered down most of what the first one achieved.

SHUNNNNNNN~

Critics have better taste than Yas Forums

Attached: ACF57B60-33E0-40A9-967D-C8F2CB78C3BD.png (1143x1554, 1.12M)

bully is the peak of the rockstar formula and one of the few times a dev realized it's better to scale down for more detail than be as big and dumb as possible. it also has 11/10 atmosphere.

bully is good but it's not better than gta 4