Was he the worst Persona protagonist ever?

I've only played 5 but if he's the worst one the the others must be down right legendary.

The P4 protag is the blandest piece of cardboard protag there is, and don't bring up the anime because that isn't the game.

If you don't find some of his dialogue responses funny an/or humourous then you're a miserable cunt.

This should have been the game where they finally stopped having a near mute protagonist.

nah Joker is perfect

but in all seriousness, P6 really should have an option to play as a male or female.

In terms of characteristics, yes because he has almost zero.

In terms of personality and impact? No. Persona 2 Innocent Sin's protagonist was such a fucking shithead that he literally ruined everyone's lives at the end of the game because he couldn't get with his gf.

not when this soiboy exists.

Attached: doorkun.jpg (740x900, 84.34K)

>Canonically fucked every girl
>Stop Death
>So based that he lived 2 extra month as an empty husk just to fulfill a promise.
Nah, hes the best

>Canonically
femc is the canon mc. cope.

Attached: Female.Protagonist.(PERSONA.3).full.980118.jpg (600x782, 143.37K)

who

minako arisato, the canon protagonist of persona 3.

Attached: Female.Protagonist.(PERSONA.3).full.850013.jpg (2160x1516, 292.36K)

Wiping All Out > Mass Destruction

Joker doesn't really feel like a protagonist that grows throughout his journey unlike the previous two.

Chad Narukami has the more soul than your emo twink
youtu.be/BbBOIQOtKb8

How does getting the third Persona forms work in P5R? Do I just see them once after maxing them and then I've got them?

Joker drew the most dimes
Fuck outta here hater

arguing the quality of one blank slate persona protag over another is peak autism.

Yes, but it has to be in the third semester. The only exception is one party member who unlocks theirs when you send the final calling card, provided you already have them maxed out.

>Not in Arena
>Not in Dancing
>Golden has Margaret tell the Investigation Team that Elizabeth left to find a way to save the "young man" who became a seal to banish humanity's desire for death
>Not an optional boss in P5R while Minato is
>"minako arisato, the canon protagonist of persona 3"

Attached: laughing whores.jpg (1000x708, 315.41K)

I see, in that case they give you hella time to do stuff in the Third Semester, I dunno why people complained it was too short. That aside, this story and content is probably the best Persona extra they've ever done, even the Answer hasn't got shit on this. And Maruki is a great 'villain' to go up against.

actually in the Jap release of P4G Margaret doesn’t mention the gender of the person in the seal even though she did in P4 vanilla

>good villian
>good tunes
>Akechi still evil as fuck

All around based
I just wish we could have gotten Satanael in it as well, literally no reason to not be able to fuse him.

There is a plot reason if you remember how he got Satanael in the first place, at least he's still in NG+

Oh man, Akechi is super fun. I thought he was just going to be passive aggressive but he's gone full on edgelord and it's great. I'm using Kasumi and Akechi in my team right now and while I'm obviously suffering for it slightly, it's great.

Did she in original P4? Wouldn't she just use okyakusama, anyway?

She's in PQ2 because she's from a different universe
The same way all the SMT Messiahs show up in Apocalypse, through different universe bullshit

nah hes kinda cute

>Was about one misstep away from getting his head blown off by a fujo
Yeah, I'd say he was the worst. In all seriousness though, taking out the Demiurge isn't even an impressive feat for a Persona protagonist. Let alone a Megaten protagonist in general, with how many over the top god figures we have sitting around. Honestly
>Door > Joker = Ziodyne

Attached: 39930303.gif (220x164, 188.21K)

nah

Attached: Rean_Schwarzer_(Sen_III).png (1414x2000, 1.78M)

I can't

Attached: image.png (880x655, 136.75K)

>THE POWER OF FRIENDSHIP

How is any of this not super generic?

Anyway the real answer is the P1 protag but Joker is miles better than Yu.

>I just wish we could have gotten Satanael in it as well, literally no reason to not be able to fuse him.

I was pretty fucking pissed that Kasumi offered to join before Qlipoth.Mementos and we turn her down, why even have her ask if we don't even get to choose? Especially when we only get her in one dungeon as is.

Google translates it as “soul of a boy”

Attached: 78FBE9F4-191D-418F-8875-B0AB60B8C86C.jpg (1684x544, 208.04K)

Please understand, anime cutscenes very expensive to redo, so we preserve original story for fans to enjoy.

Retard
In terms of power level it's
Makoto
Tetsuya
Joker
Yu
Maya
P1 Protag

try not to mix so much seethe in with your cope.

Attached: femc-pq2.png (586x800, 802.47K)

this, that kid is a fag, and the worst thing in the game
the girl version is superior purely for having a generalized cheery personality, vs. the standard protagonist's flat nothingness
>but that's intentional!
it's still boring and he looks like a queer

Oh, wow, yup, that's right. It's gender neutral in Golden.

I just got that moment and it's legitimately one of the must frustrating moments in Royal since you can tell they played with the idea because why the hell else would she go instantly from her second to third tier Persona
I like Royal a lot, but the Shido to Yaldy is a mess because the Royal story stuff pretty much disappears for that portion of the game

I don’t think you know what a fujo is

no, they have set personalities even in the games, which are compounded on in the anime adaptations or mangas or whatever
P3 kid is a flat emo kid
P4 kid is a weirdo and kind of a perv
P5 kid is a tryhard cool guy

tatsuya is way more powerful than the rest of them, nova kaiser makes him extremely op.

They're all peak Mary Sue. Least p3 killed it's guy off.

All 3rd Persona's look suckass anyway, why did they revert to being just advanced forms of the first form? Morgana spends 95% of the game with his trash tier Persona esign, finally gets a cool design before Qlipoth and fucking loses it again for 'ZZorro...with a nicer suit' edition.

You're the one coping. She's even listed in PQ2 as from P3P, not P3, where all the others come from.

>why did they revert to being just advanced forms of the first form?
Play the game

>listed as the star of the best-selling version of p3
rightfully so.

Which is kind of irrelevant since they refer to him as a male in the arena games anyway. And PQ2 confirms Theo was her canon attendant

Doesn't matter
Makoto got the Universe arcana
Literally the only reason he's above him, you can argue that they're tied though

Joker has no flavour really. 3 and 4's protags were blank slates of course but their look and mannerisms and portrayal in anime made them distinct.

5 is kind of like that all around, the only area it shines in particularly, is being very stylish. I find it strange joker is pushed as a character for smash etc.

She's canon
Just in a different universe

nobody cares about some special snowflake arcana. tatsuya would just stunlock door-cuck with nova kaiser.

Yes

Nova Kaiser is weaksauce.

They don’t though, hell they hardly even reference him at all. The few that do don’t mention gender either

Would a P2 remake even work?

>I find it strange joker is pushed as a character for smash etc.
You find it strange that the most recent protag was the used for smash?
Basically half of all fans of a persona game have never played nor have any knowledge of the preceding game, this applies to each successive release because they have always gotten more popular each time

Yeah but as a 2 in 1 pack.

>Tatswhoya would stunlock the king of stunlocks

Attached: 1584244045395.png (296x438, 24.46K)

i don't see why it couldn't. all they really have to do is translate the artstyle over to 3d, make the dungeons less tedious, and copy p5's battle system/qol features. they don't have to touch the plot or the soundtrack.

Here's some quotes from Elizabeth's story
>That is why he tried to protect his bonds with his life... Leading him into the Universe
>I thought by defeating it, I could see him again

door-cuck literally died to trash mob fodder from smt games. tatsuya could probably beat him while holding back, just like roido-sama did to rean, haha...

Attached: jobber rean confirms his 0-1 record against roido-sama.png (1920x1080, 2.79M)

yeah ok. duck hunt is in the game.

>loves all his friends equally instead of obsessing over a robot or gay detective
>still the only one with a persona of the World Arcana
>girls don’t even get mad if he cheats on them
>has idols and gods begging for his dick
>didn’t die like a bitch and gets to enjoy life with his friends and loved ones
still the king

Attached: 77E4BA1A-8314-4771-A94D-E75BA9A77B97.jpg (544x544, 321.6K)