Rank all zelda games!
tiermaker.com
Rank all zelda games!
Jack James
William Wright
Jack Brooks
Glad you like the handhelds user, I'm more of a 3D zelda fan though
Jordan White
Just finished Wind Waker for the first time (HD)
Was really fucking good
Honestly so far all 6 Zelda games I played have been amazing
Jackson Jones
Something like this
honestly I'm underrating the original here but then again I do like the games above it a lot more, despite what the original brought
If it's not on there, I didn't play it
Dylan Nelson
Prove me wrong retards
Camden Campbell
>ALTTP and BOTW
but why
David Ramirez
>MM
You're wrong. It's literally everything wrong with BotW but people forget that because they weren't alive back then
Mason Long
Jaxson Martinez
Hyrule Warriors is not a zelda game, mate.
Samuel Ramirez
Chase Morris
Sebastian Gutierrez
BOTW = generic open world garbage. Older games had a pass for this because of technical limitations.
ALTTP = boring bosses and shitty hitboxes.
Michael Nelson
>generic open world garbage. Older games had a pass for this because of technical limitations.
Agreed. But MM should be painted with this same brush then. It's dungeons are only moderately better than BotW's "dungeons" and the main draw is a shitty "open world" and it's vastly overrated side quests that fuel the collect-a-thon of masks, even though people criticise BotW for being a collect-a-thon of equally pointless things
Luke Price
Bentley Kelly
I play video games for the atmosphere so MM is insta SS for me. The game feels very intricate.
Kayden Williams
PH was so bland that I skipped Spirit Tracks.
Juan Barnes
I'm judging the GBA port of ALTTP on the basis of the Four Swords stuff; as an overall port it's pretty solid.
Jace Myers
Skyward Sword
Nathaniel Sanchez
>botw overwhelmingly rated mediocre ITT
only chads in here right now love you bros
James Carter
I agree, SS is shit
Logan Butler
>my-image
Ethan Bailey
It's basically a Mario game's structure with Zelda logic for the level design. Nothing wrong with that. Fine game.
Joshua White
Kayden Cook
Gonna piss people off but how I feel is how I feel
Give it a chance. It's a huge step up
Noah Ward
I don't dislike any Zelda games includinb the CDI ones they're so bad it shoots right past bad they're kinda fun.
Brody Martinez
D - means: haven't played it enough to form a really conclusive opinion.
TP would be A/S if I could replay it and skip most of the long boring parts, it's base gameplay is really solid, pacing is just all over the place.
Didn't get to complete MM / ALTTP / Oracles, but have played enough of either to form a pretty conclusive opinion.
Jaxon Wright
I meant S/SS in regards to TP
Nathaniel Cox
>BOTW
>SS tier
Christopher Gutierrez
Ny first time through BotW is the most fun I've had with a Zelda by a mile. I can't ignore that even if it loses its edge on replays
Anthony Morris
ALL pretty good :)
Grayson Ortiz
Aside from being really excited for Twilight Princess when the Wii was first coming out, I don't care much for Zelda as franchise as a whole (when compared to other Nintendo IPs)
BOTW was the first Zelda to blow me away.
Matthew Walker
Chase Taylor
Thomas Watson
Mine. Replaying alttp right now
Jeremiah Jackson
Adrian Collins
ok
Camden Lewis
I think BotW is pretty boring but I wish I felt the love for it other people do. I bought it expecting the best and ended up getting kind of bored with it before I even made it to the second Divine Beast.
Adam Perez
Now I'm not saying Ocarina of Time hasn't aged well.
...I'm just saying it's aged about as well as Smash Bros. Wii U.
Eli Thomas
The only correct ranking
Owen Powell
So the oracle games are pretty good, then? I never got the chance to play them.
How much you get out of breath of the wild depends on how much you enjoy fucking around with the physics engine. A lot of it is kind of "making your own game," since the tasks it presents to you can be done efficiently in a mundane way, or you can see what kind of goofy shit you can come up with to do them to keep yourself entertained. It's kind of like gmod.
Nathan Carter
Edit fixed
Liam Richardson
I digress, most of the fun in BOTW was walking around this huge world and discovering a new location (although it would have been cool to have good dungeons and more obscure secrets like heart pieces)
Eli Edwards
Now that I think about it I'd probably drop Majora's Mask lower. I want to rank it high-ish because it's unique and more interesting than the other 3D Zeldas, but I don't actually enjoy the game itself that much.
Christopher Jenkins
Finally. I thought we'd go an entire thread without le epic contrarian post.
Justin Roberts
>wants to play Majora's Mask but I never can
The 3 day/time system just kills it for me. And the first part as Deku Scrub Link just didn't grab me
Jack Moore
Based and AoL Death Mountain pulled.
Jaxson Edwards
The time system is the coolest part of the game, user. Don't think of it as a time limit, because you can never fail anything by running out of time.
Asher Wilson
Learn a sequence break to do the goron or zora parts early, or just put some mask cheats on in the emulator, that's what I used to do
Thomas James
>but the game is fun !
Woman-tier
Connor Parker
What else am I supposed to judge it on?
Josiah Campbell
nigga u gay
Liam Wilson
Read a book on ludology before you ever post here again, faggot.
Grayson Lewis
David Roberts
Story, music, graphical details, level design, etc. The weight of each depending on what you enjoy in video games.
Jayden Turner
Michael Miller
I've been meaning to. Just finished replaying ALBW after Minish Cap and the Oracles.
Justin Carter
If you play games for fun this isn't the website for you.
Logan Hernandez
I'm about to start seasons and ages. If they aren't as good as you're claiming then I will find you.
Michael Roberts
Uh, OP... You forgot a couple...
Bentley Barnes
That's why I have multiple games in my top tier, because they all excel in different ways.
I hear this a lot but no one ever explained what they play games for instead
Dylan Walker
>People write books on this shit
Who the fuck would actually pay to read that?
Jackson Brooks
Matthew Brooks
Christopher James
It also opens up a lot of possibilities in how quests can play out, since failing one might open up others you can do instead.
Cooper Butler
Asher Jenkins
Juan Morales
Isaiah Martin
Bad taste incoming
Caleb Torres
I'd have probably put ALBW far above ALttP and top tier in general if only the dungeons weren't so straightforward and same-y and it was so easy to tank hits.