The choice that divided /v

Why do you fags still say this? She was still an infected psycho that almost killed you on multiple occasions, cut off your hand, and was willingly involved in the experimentation on children.

Amazing isnt?And they fucking double down on hillbilly punch Man DLC with making the choice of saving the wife not only Canon but the one that makes you saving both.

Zoe saved you and is clearly in love with you. She also a cute. While Mia an ugly bitch who cuts your hand, works for the Umbrella and lied to you about everything.

Wow what a difficult choice indeed.

this

Attached: 1485962233908.png (1920x1080, 1.49M)

>She was still an infected psycho that almost killed you on multiple occasions, cut off your hand...
Damn, if only you had the means to cure her and get her back to her real, non possessed psycho self...
>...and was willingly involved in the experimentation on children.
Do you even know that when you make the choice? And besides that, you'd think you'd want to hear YOUR WIFE explain that part instead of curing a random girl you met a few hours earlier.

You Miafags with you "SHE'S YOUR WIFE" excuse still exist? Why care about Mia when you the whole game has you experiencing how much of a cunt and liability the she is even before she was infected? The player isn't Ethan. Everything we see about Mia is that she was involved with a criminal bioweapon engineering organization and spent most of the game trying to kill you.

Attached: cookie no shitto.gif (520x375, 331.51K)

>you'd think you'd want to hear YOUR WIFE
She's not the player's wife.

How did an inbred redneck like Zoe know how to make an antidote without any lab equipment?

Ogre

or

Ogre 2: The Revengening

yeah, hard choice

The one that isn't a crazy fucking bitch that tried to murder me with a fucking chainsaw, cutting my fucking hand in the process, thanks.

>if only you had the means to cure her and get her back to her real, non possessed psycho self...
Her real self is still responsible for what happened in the game.
>you'd think you'd want to hear YOUR WIFE explain that part instead
Why do you faggots keep harping on that she's Ethan's wife? Who the fuck cares when the whole game has her portrayed as an antagonist who was involved in a criminal conspiracy and tried to kill you over and over?
>curing a random girl you met a few hours earlier.
That random girl was an innocent civilian who spent the whole game helping you.

Attached: 1386721575767.png (112x124, 33.06K)

There are two kinds of people
>Shallow as fuck people
>People who played the DLC
Mia was part of the problem and kept things from you
Zoe just wanted the life that was stolen back

>Zoe saved you
Because she needed you to move around and pick up shit she couldn't.
>and is clearly in love with you
lmfao she's known you for a couple hours and not even face to face. I mean, she staples your gun while your unconscious and that's really it until you find both girls way later. Are you a nice guy or incel by any chance? Jesus Christ.
>She also a cute
No one is a cute in the RE Engine.
>While Mia an ugly bitch who cuts your hand
She's the sole reason you went there in the first place, your main objective, and she wasn't herself. She bashes her head against a wall to stop hurting you and returns to her self when you defeat her. You'd think the black eyes and veins around the face would be a give away.
>works for the Umbrella
False.
>and lied to you about everything
You'd think that'd be something interesting to talk about given that she's supposed to be the person you love instead of leaving her behind on a swamp over a literal who to Ethan.
>Wow what a difficult choice indeed.
I know, right? Enjoy the bad ending and losing both girls btw.

The player is not Ethan. Are you one of those that thinks Spec Ops is blaming the player?

>3 years later
>the only defense miafags can only come up with is repeating that she was the initial goal for Ethan of the game
I'd hate to use the meme of the week but Miafags truly are simps.

Attached: 1473789433929.png (434x480, 183.21K)

They're both hideous so you really do have to make a choice, which is kind of nice. You either pick Zoe for being a bro to you or you pick Ethan's hoe because that's the whole reason you're even playing the game.

Soo felling proud of saving no one?Top kek enjoy having to pay for a new phone while my Ethan can cuckquean his wife with a southern belle bcause he save both by making THE RIGHT CHOICE.

Attached: tenor (1).gif (248x202, 666.52K)

Because it's a video game. What the player sees and discovers matters over the basic backgrounds of characters. Also, I like how you responded to that simple post instead of every other post pointing out that she was part of a group experimenting bioweapons on children and kept killing you repeatedly throughout the game.

She saw Mia notes...i guess its explained in one of the Dlcs

>Why care about Mia
Because it's the whole reason the game even starts, it's the MC's objective. Why care about Mary in Silent Hill if you don't even "meet" her until the endings?
when [...] the whole game has you experiencing how much of a cunt and liability [...] she is even before she was infected?
Except you don't really get that until her flashbacks which happen AFTER the choice. Up until then you just know she sent you a message imploring you to leave her be, when you find her on the bed she wants you to leave asap, then she's infected and the couple times she can break from the possession she tries to knock herself out and tells you she lives you.
>The player isn't Ethan
Acting as him or not is your choice. Fucking up nets you a bad ending, simple as.

>Soo felling proud of saving no one?
Not really but it happened. I'm not a developer.

They're both hideous, and I would neither fuck nor save either one of them. Period. Fucked hotter looking fuckin' hookers than those piles of shit.

Attached: image.jpg (460x621, 128.47K)

>The only defense
Forgeting the fact we get both girls if we save the Right one AKA Mia?
You dont get it?we cucked you own choice by having both girls while the tards that choose Zoe have none.
>YFW you just got cucked by a simp

Attached: tenor.gif (110x90, 121K)

But you didnt lost your hand

>Her real self is still responsible for what happened in the game.
Which you don't entirely know when doing the choice
>Why do you faggots keep harping on that she's Ethan's wife?
Because it's the whole point of him being there.
>Who the fuck cares
Ethan, seeing it's what he chose. Enjoy the bad ending bro
>when the whole game has her portrayed as an antagonist
The game has her portrayed as someone that wanted Ethan to never come get her because she didn't want to put him in danger and as someone who isn't herself when fucking black veins start growing around her head
>who was involved in a criminal conspiracy
Only found out after the fact.
>and tried to kill you over and over?
Literally not her.
>That random girl was an innocent civilian
Who Ethan has known for an hour compared to Mia
>who spent the whole game helping you.
Because she can't get to the items and needs you to do it for her. Ethan getting there was a blessing for her.

This.
>criminal responsible for infecting an entire innocent family
>"But she's your wife!"
>lied to you and and helped put the world at risk of a dangerous virus
>"But she's your wife!"
>was nearly a lost cause like most of the other infected characters and kept trying to get you killed
>"But she's your wife!"
Miafags have the minds of romance-novel-loving middle aged women.

Attached: 1533234832765.jpg (250x250, 6.98K)

Imagine choosing inbred redneck over cute secret organization operative

That is why i need at least one more RE with my boy Ethan just to see hin with Zoe when his wife obviously was arrested after the whole mess.Just to pour more salt on Zoefags

>Enjoy the bad ending bro
I did because the bitch of a wife who helped cause all this still died.

>Because it's a video game.
What a retarded fucking excuse. Do you even know where you are? Can't you get immersed "hurr durr it's a videogame" is a take I'd expect from Twitter.
>What the player sees and discovers matters over the basic backgrounds of characters.
Porque no los dos.
>Also, I like how you responded to that simple post instead of every other post pointing out that she was part of a group experimenting bioweapons on children and kept killing you repeatedly throughout the game.
You must be blind then.

Good for you :)

>Can't you get immersed "hurr durr it's a videogame" is a take I'd expect from Twitter
You Miafags are the one arguing against being immersed since you want people to only follow Ethan's initial goal instead of choosing the safest choice.

>he played the non-existant DLCs when the game first came out
>he played the extra stories DLCs before playing the main game
smol brain

Mia didn't try to murder you, Eveline did.

>Can't you get immersed "hurr durr it's a videogame"
Are you an illiterate retard? That's the main reason people don't choose Mia and that's been said over and over again. People get immersed in the game and realize that wanting to save Mia is more trouble than it's worth.

I love how Yas Forums acts like they don't love the shit out of Ada when she's a worse Mia

>whore 1 vs whore 2

i don't get it.

>arguing against being immersed
>by choosing not only what Ethan would cleary choose, but also the confirmed canon choice

what game

giving agency to the player automatically negates the will of the "character"
that's why silent protagonists make the most sense

Yeah, sure, of course. Crazy ass bitch...

>That's the main reason people don't choose Mia
But it's not. You make the choice entirely through the eyes of John McNugget the guy sitting on front of the screen, not Ethan Winters the guy you've been playing as for 6+ hours. Then repeat over and over "Mia totally wants to cut your arm off bro it's totally her own free will"

>people say repeatedly that were thinking as they would in the game
>they still don't choose to save mia
>"Hurr you just didn't get immersed!"

Attached: nick-young-confused-face-300x256-nqlyaa.jpg (800x450, 23.88K)

>Right told you to use the syringe
>Use it
She used her syringe on her old man.

>Oh but Ada is hot soo ooga booga boobies

Oh i cant wait if Capcom use Mia again with a improved and hotter model soo the horde of fags claiming that always liked Mia.

I personally always find the face model the cutest

Attached: 455full-savannah-daniels.jpg (455x563, 46.81K)

>[they] were thinking as they would in the game
Leave that for games like TES. You're not (You) in RE7, "you're" Ethan. Ethan would save his wife. And he did. Canon, happy ending.

People did get immersed, dumbass. And then they decided if they wanted to save an infected madwoman who happened to be the character's wife or the hillbilly girl that was helping you throughout the game. You are jumping through a lot of hoops just to repeat the old wife argument.

Attached: 1389578106722.jpg (393x315, 21.58K)

I'll take the boat

If devs made it canon and the "happy ending," why do you care so much about people choosing Zoe?

>the choice that divided Yas Forums
Wouldn't that be Triss vs Yennefer?

Attached: 2018227171620_1.jpg (1280x720, 109.08K)

Because this is a discussion board and I like to discuss shit. The alternative would be not doing shit and staring at the ceiling because corona has me chilling at home more than usual.

Canon isn't free from criticism, dude.

>who happened to be the character's wife
So they didn't get immersed, got it.

So you went from arguing from player immersion to staunchly adhering to canon. You're really desperate.

youtu.be/YgHNtzxO0y8

Attached: vl4eqakfrpr21.jpg (499x385, 107.86K)

>She was the WHOLE fucking reason why you came out this hick infested waste land.
Exactly. Let her rot.

Yennefer is clearly the superior choice, everyone knows that.

Ethan saving his wife is just the prompt of the game, dude. How the story plays out and how players feel about it still matters more.

But it shows what people in-universe would and did actually do. It's, dare I say it, what makes the most sense.

based as fuck

Are you now going to say that just because devs/writers make something canon that it automatically makes sense?

Reminder that you would never meet the best Character If you have choose Zoe.
People that choose Zoe cant get a break kek

Attached: 22459553_1645600715460809_2277084787645695216_o.jpg (1920x1080, 175.58K)

You came of your own volition. She very explicitly didn't want you to.

>It's canon so it makes sense!
And you had the gall to say the other anons had the mind of a twitter user.

Attached: 273325-56231-one-more-day.jpg (640x640, 53.76K)

is there a mod to make those two not ugly as fuck?
every other re game has naked pregnant futa mods but there's nothing for 7

It made sense for most players to go with Mia, and it made enough for sense for them to make it the option to go forward with, so yes?

user, just because they write something to be a certain way, that doesn't mean they make sense. Especially evidenced by Ethan's earliest actions when first compromised by the family.

Attached: maxresdefault.jpg (1280x720, 65.7K)

Fucking this. I’m gonna save my wife first before some random girl

>dude this comic is shit therefore every single canon ever is bad
Comics, fucking really? It's not like it's not universally hated or anything, unlike this choice where most people actually chose Mia

Ethan was generally considered to be a stupid antagonist fueled by lose marriage adherence. Even the most loving person wouldn't give the same amount of mercy to their parents or siblings as Ethan did to Mia.

Your responses are becoming more and more contrived.

Attached: 1380893826882.png (429x410, 11.5K)

>Especially evidenced by Ethan's earliest actions when first compromised by the family.
Explain

What choice? It's either continue the game or a really long game over sequence.

I choose...Sherry!

If I had to choose based on ther beauty I would just trow a coin and let fate decide, because whatever.

Resident Evil used to have kino designs like pic related. Nowadays it's just "realistic" bullshit they keep pushing.

Attached: ab68695fb712f296a0a4453ef9a6b216.jpg (1000x1600, 120.18K)

>It makes sense because the devs made it canon.
>It makes since because more people chose it.
So now you went from arguing from authority to arguing by ad populum. Good job.

>Ethan was generally
I'd like to see numbers
>Even the most loving person wouldn't give the same amount of mercy to their parents or siblings as Ethan did to Mia.
Both times she's herself and not a possessed puppet she very clearly shows she didn't want Ethan to be there, didn't want to hurt him and wanted him to GTFO of there and leave her.
>Your responses are becoming more and more contrived.
kek

Mia is the canonical choice. Zoe ends up ok anyway, thanks to Uncle Joe.

It's both you retard. A shows it's what the developers though was the best choice, B shows it's what the players thought was the best choice.

So devs and players both can't make stupid choices to you?