Rank them

Super Metroid (the classic that started it all) > Ori (quite linear, mid tier but better than the rest) > Hollow Knight (babby's first metroidvania) > Rogue Legacy (not even a metroidvania btw)

Attached: 1530896859760.gif (185x185, 36.03K)

I like Kirby and the Amazing Mirror the best.

SM >>> Ori >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> HK
Never played the 3rd gamr, so I can't rank it.

Rabi-Ribi>Ori>Metroid
Didn't play knight game and hollow knight is trash

Attached: 8lwBqCnTMCs.jpg (460x215, 65.11K)

HK>ori>metroid i dont know the 3rd one so i cant say anything

Rogue Legacy isn't a metroidvania, OP's image is retarded.
How can you rank them if you don't even know what one of the games is? Then again I'm retarded for replying to obvious bait.

>ori
>metroidvania

good one, OP

Attached: 1561238425043.jpg (900x900, 174.75K)

Hollow Knight was great until they kept adding content just to pander to vidya masochists.
Seriously, you can say "git gud" all you like but some of the content in that game is unreasonably difficult.

>Ori
>metroidvania
dude, i love this game but it's too linear

Attached: 1512608222298.gif (171x172, 961.68K)

Castlevania = Metroid > everything else.

Attached: metroidvania.jpg (3074x926, 346.43K)

People on Yas Forums can’t be this retarded, can they?

what is the prettiest metroidvania whilst still being a good game? I still think its shadow complex, hands down. Hollow knight, metroids and ori are still good but I'm tired of the 2d art style. Shadow complex is the only one I know of to utilize a 3d art style and actually incorporate things in the foreground and background.

>indieshit on both sides
no

Rogue legacy isn't a metroidvania, op image is retarded wherever it came from.

The Switch eshop has a surprising number of good metroidvanias, even some I would call hidden gems, especially for how cheap they are and how well the genre works on handheld devices
anyone played Blasphemous yet? how is it? I liked the demo, seemed a tad easy, though

Metroidlike =/= Metroidvania

Attached: Metroidvanias.jpg (2000x8200, 3.45M)

Met > Hollow > Oni >legacy

super > hollow > literally who #1 > literally who #2

for me its valdis story

>nooooooooooooooooo, you can't just add optional content that is difficult

>what should we add to our game who's main strength is exploration
>a bunch of "follow the pattern of my moves or die, also don't use any of your powerups " boss fights connected by a linear hub world, the exact opposite of exploration

Based purely on gameplay, Metroid Fusion is the peak of the genre

nigger you dont even know what the game on the Yas Forums side is
no one on this board does

Based purely on gameplay, no Metroid game is as good as any Castlevania game.

>1.- Hollow Knight (by far)
>2.- Metroid
>3.- Ori

>4.- Yeah that game

>wonder boy
>good tier

>monster boy
>only good tier

>messenger
>only good

>Yoku island express
>not shit

>pirates curse not a metroidvania even though it is

>ESA not in God tier

>literal homosexual fudge-packed Alucard in Trinity when it should be faggot tier now

>La-mulana in trinity because hurrrr it's hard
>don't even refute me nigger I beat the hell temple, lick my pussy and my crack you simp faggot.

you're pathetic--the only person in this thread to even play all those games is me.

Ori 1 is not a metroidvania.

my favorite metroidvania is Metal Gear Solid

>la mulana that high
if this tier list is for games that fit the genre the most, then i guess? but the game itself isn't that good

fpbp

Procedural generation makes for a shit metroidvania, but the game can still be fun.

Metroidvania are about complexly interconnected level design not randomized trash.

It's optional retard. You can get 100% without even touching it so cool your autism.

>doesn't even have pic related on it

Attached: Anubis_and_the_Buried_Bone.jpg (1280x720, 98.23K)

It is that good though. Also SotN is up there so being amazing isn't a requirement anyway. That game's only a challenge for like one hour and the inverted castle is ass.

d..don't summon the creaking skull.

at leats we can all agree that Hollow Knight is objectively better than Super Metroid

furfags get out

they could've spent the time they put into this dumb shit on getting silksong out faster, or adding actually worthwhile content to the game that plays to it's strengths, or improved issues with what they already had

i do

Attached: 1516065805206.jpg (960x677, 103.69K)

Timespinner and Environmental Station Alpha were awful though, they should be at the bottom.

It's La Mulana
What do I win?

Attached: 1552266686802.jpg (600x400, 82.68K)

There are no issues with the game, it's perfect. There's no point in adding another optional area since a Boss Rush was what people were asking for so they delivered. I'll give you the Silksong point though.

>t. ori was my first metroidvania AND PROUD OF IT

Timespinner is very playable if you skip all dialogue

TSA is good, the main story at least. After that it becomes too cryptic and repetitive.

What was wrong with Timespinner?

>furfags get out
user when the day of reckoning happens we will need their help

That's not even the game he's talking about...

>Metroidvania
>Underbound
>Wolfendoom
>Command & Craft
>Harvestcrossing
>Pactris
>Niohsouls
>Silentevil
>FireCOM
>Granforza
>Falloutscrolls
>Hollowcells
>Baldurscape
>Sonrio
>Banjokong
>EASports
>Farcreed

Attached: Soyboy Wojak (475).jpg (600x800, 79.48K)

____________I know___________

>want to have a comfy castlevania thread
>find a thread and discuss with likeminded peers
>suddenly smell something foul
>no...DEAR GOD NO
>the smashfags are nearing closer to derail the thread
>proceed to distribute the industrial gasmasks
>door bursts and brace for the worst
>oh my god
>NO
>it was far worse than a smelly smashfag
>it was the dreaded hollow knigger
>HOLLOW KNIGHT IS THE BEST HOLLOWVANIA. THAT'S RIGHT. THE GENRE
SHOULD BE RENAMED AFTER THE SUPREME TITLE.
>the vapid stench causes some of the gas masks to vaporize into thin air
>those without masks soon dissolve into a black and dull goo
>try to escape
>IT'S FUNNY HOW HOLLOW KNIGHT IS ONLY ONE GAME YET IT MANAGED TO OUTCLASS EVERY SINGLE PILE OF SHIT IN THIS MEDIOCRE SERIES
>suddenly eyes begin to burn
>desperately claw at my mask
>realize it has been punctured
>can feel my eyes oozing out into my mouth
>as i drown on my own
>the last thing i hear before drifting into darkness is incoherent rambling about gamefeel

This is the type of melodramatic dribble all Castlevaniafags sound like whenever someone brings up one (1) game

>Noooooooooo
>people can't like well known or popular things!!!!

Attached: 1556631565294.gif (636x288, 1.73M)

what's a better name
Exploration platformer?

>La-Mulana
>Indieshit
fuck you mang

>What's a better name? Something descriptive and indicative of the actual gameplay?

Attached: Soyboy Wojak (1).png (644x800, 14.63K)

>starting a non-specific metroidvania general
You wanted a shitstorm, didn't you, OP? Okay:

1. Metroid
2. Hollow Knight
3. Ori barely counts as a metroidvania
4. Rogue Legacy isn't a metoridvania and is also a shit game

I'll never understand why Yas Forums has such a hate boner for Hollow Knight

It was originally one guy that hated it so much he spammed every thread. Now I dunno, haven't been in a HK thread in a while so maybe that one guy succeeded forcing the meme that its the reddit game.