Is this good or bad character design?

I'ts ok. SMTIV's design is kino...

I like nanashi's design! I think it fits in well with SMTIV's Tokyo.

reminds me of this.

Attached: 1561712192311.jpg (536x609, 62.59K)

Better than Persona's fuccbois

not as good as this guy though

Attached: 1554939197204.jpg (1280x960, 850.04K)

>character design is so bad that it is good.

Attached: St蒼葉_通常_normal.png (340x533, 137.34K)

What does Yas Forums think of this guy's design?

Attached: 1456327339250.png (538x405, 189.19K)

He looks like he fucks young anime girls

You better believe it baby

i can't not see Yas Forums's clover on his hand

Seems pretty appropriate for Tokyo Filth to wear. The half-shaved hairstyle has always been fucking stupid though.

Appropriate

Attached: 1582747421705.jpg (218x231, 12.74K)

>he almost had a good design
Still mad.

Attached: Nanashi_Initial_Design_SMTIVF.jpg (373x554, 79.02K)

He's the second cutest SMT male protag after Demi-fiend.

too old

Gay just like Demifiend.

>DAGDA SAID IT'S MY TURN TO BE THE MESSIAH

fuck off fag

Attached: 3771dnth4rc41.png (354x500, 179.37K)

He's modeled after Travis bickle

It's a mohawk, it's literally Travis bickle, hence having the pins

It's ok for what they were going for (a punk kid) outside of the exposed leg of his jumpsuit, but he looks better in the maid outfit

Attached: Strange Journey Redux Neutral end.jpg (1680x1050, 576.4K)

He looks cute, I'd fuck him.

I wish I was this guy, what an Uber chad

make him young if you must but let him keep the hat and glasses

Too bad he'll always be on the bottom screen in combat.

FF has no good designs, shit series and babbies first jrpg

nanashi is a actually good character design for protagonist, flynn is the worst and fujobait.
nanashi is convetinally attractive without being a fujobait character he got these super cool edgy eybrows that make him look Yas Forums and edgy markings around his eyes and nose that give him a rough appearance his hair is scuffed and edgy. Nanashi looks like SMT protagonist, Flynn looks gay.

>inb4 SMTV is being delayed to make way for a nocturne remake first

Attached: 2973192731.jpg (383x366, 11.1K)

nice Retardyne, too bad Yas Forums is immune

FF has better design than 90% of westren shit. Compare XIV armor designs to WoW.

Attached: 51bba96bf39c7359-bd0b2c040cd3763a947acd6d7ed05a61-1200x600.jpg (1200x600, 52.24K)

Dragoon is better

The producer mentioned it back in 2018. Kind of surprised they didn't do that as a trial run with UE4 / HD development before jumping into V proper.

looks like some Hot Topic trash. What the fuck happened to SMT? Why can't we just get a clean shaven everyday man that I can self-insert into? Fucking hell.

Attached: DSJ_Protagonist_render.png (463x1217, 471.6K)

>tfw Alex is the guest character for this version

Attached: tenor.gif (220x221, 76.91K)

Flynn looks like a traditional Samurai, even if they tend to look feminine, Samurai are way cooler than punk teenagers, and actually have experience in real combat.

Edgy tryhard teenagers are way gayer than ancient Samurai in my eyes, even though a lot of them fucked boys.

>Alex
>Not Tatsuya Suou who somehow got trapped in the Vortex World post-EP

>What the fuck happened to SMT? Why can't we just get a clean shaven everyday man that I can self-insert into?
Do you mean young high school boys like in SMT1/3 or a young adult like in SMT2/4?

>P2 existing
It'll never happen, but that brought the possibility of P5 Joker being the guest character to my mind, and that horrifies me.

Why was the art for SMT IV so inconsistent and lazy?

>inb4 SMT V is Law Nocturne
>Secret boss is True Demon Demi Fiend

Attached: metasurvivor.jpg (686x526, 174.82K)

Design:
Aleph>Raidou>Demi-Fiend>Kazuya>Nanashi>SJ protagonist>Flynn

Doi did the human characters and they had a bunch of guest artists do all the demons, some way worse than others

>Law Nocturne
But Nocturne was Law Nocturne. Shijima and Yosuga are literally codified law systems which enforce a strict order and Musubi only misses because you cannot have a Law universe in a world with one person.

They hired multiple guest artists who had little to no knowledge of the series. Many of the artists they hired were veterans of the sentai and toku genres, a genre famous for ridiculous designs. Giving a series meant to depict mythology in an accurate and appropriate way to artists like that was just a dumb move in general and resulted in nearly all the new demon designs being awful, at least we got minotaur though.

The demon art? Due to multiple guest designers with very different style art styles. If the game at least were 3d they could have hidden that factor somewhat, but with big boss sprites directly based on the art for most new demons covering the entire screen their different art styles immediately stand out.

I'd rather have a SMT1 or 2 Remake desu. I always wanted to see tokyo millennium in 3D. Or there being more concept art of it floating about
If you mean demon designs, the new ones were by guest artists, and some were pretty much the concept scanned without any touching up like how IVA did with having Doi redraw returning ones in hid own artstyle. Other than that it's the usual clash between Kaneko's eras of artstyles with demons and Doi's designs for humans.

All the reasons are law because the cycle of creation is god's will.

>Dante is replaced by Joker

Attached: 19732491723.png (475x792, 490.21K)

If it makes you feel better there's an interview where an artist said his own son told him his designs were shit and that Kaneko's are better.

I wouldn't be surprised if Joker makes a cameo and steals all the spotlight.

>his own son told him his designs were shit and that Kaneko's are better
Get fucking told.

Attached: 1552707810654.png (765x687, 200.17K)

Nah, it has outright been said in interviews that Nocturne is Chaos inspired due to the whole "demon infested world with its fate chosen by their fight" aspect.

Law in SMT is generally specifically YHVH's law and that doesn't cover random fucks getting to create their own world. Although Nocturne in general was initially created to move away from all that set up, but then Maniax tries to move back to it, which is why you end up with the whole situation kind of inconsistent and contradictory (like YHVH being associated with the Great Will, but at the same time apparently he tries to use the Messians to stop the conception from starting, which makes no sense since the whole cycle is ordered by the Great Will).

If Joker didn't appear yet in the Gacha of all things, then I'm sure that this scenario hopefully won't happen.
right?

Wasn't SMT II the lawfag game?

Demifiend but bad

I is Neutral
II is Law
III is Chaos
SJ is Commander Gore
IV is a soft reboot of I and Neutral
IVA is Persona

I like his design a lot actually. I want to adopt him.

There's a SMT crossover I REALLY want but the chances are low since it's not 2008 anymore.

Attached: eemwanr.png (512x448, 6.88K)

Looks like Walter if he grew up in Tokyo instead of Mikado

>edgy teenager in pants and a bunch of boring line body tattoos is good
He's literally autism bait

>IV had that one fujo insert character
>IV:A almost goes full persona but leaves a option to kill all your friends for the old fanbase.

The problem is that SMT almost bankrupt Atlus while Persona saved it, the more waifushit/husbadoshit it has the more fujo/coomer money it rakes.

>still no translations
I've always wondered, if IVA's characters were put in another spinoff instead of mainline (anything else other than persona), would they get less flak, or will they still be shat on regardless for their execution?

Attached: pope.jpg (800x450, 26.89K)

Is woke hipster degenerate good character design? No, he looks like a Bernie bro, female to male tranny 70k in debt from a gender studies degree signalling he/she is suicidal now.

Part of me wants Massacre Nanashi to be the superboss of V or some shit.

Yas Forumstards don't know shit about character design go suck a dick.

>bro thanks for saving me
>actually no you were kinda late. fuck you I’m gonna get strong and make an autism paradise for everyone
Isamu was so retarded it’s unreal

is this good or bad character design

Attached: tsubasa.jpg (1280x720, 193.81K)

He doesn't even get strong. He literally just runs away and borrows everyone else's power for the rest of the series.
He really does speak to the kinds of people who would want that ideology. The fact he even admits he just wants to shitpost without any repercussions IRL really just adds to that.

i want to motorboat tsubasa's tsubasas

Arguably yes in context of the game it's for.