Why do people constantly shit on the British as not Germanic? Even the so-called Celtic parts have really high levels of Germanic blood, especially Scotland (almost everybody in Scotland lives within 40-60% areas). On top of that they almost all speak a West Germanic language as their native (and in most cases only) tongue.
On top of that doesn't the residual 'Celtic' DNA (R1b-L21) in the British Isles actually come from the Rhineland and cluster most closely by far with Germanic peoples anyway?
What's going on? Is this some Jewish bullshit or something? I get they seem a bit subhuman because they're an island dwelling people and a bit inbred (much like bumfuck Austrian mountainfolk don't seem very Germanic either) but I think it's a bit of a 'No True Scotsman' mindset to try and claim they're not really Germanic due to that.
Anglos evolved from Germanics just as Germanics evolved from Euros and Man evolved from ape.
Zachary White
Well I'm from Scotland and consider myself to be Germanic and merely a regional subgroup of English. I'd like to see great co-operation and closeness between the Germanic peoples, would be nice if the Irish and Welsh abandoned their Celt0id meme tier LARP identity too and embraced their Germanicness.
Carson Morgan
First off denmark is ~100% germanic.
That said Danish is the most supreme PURE race in the world. Anything superior to it is a mongrel of it. This is why the swiss and the broad anglo saxon (southwest scandinavian) region of europe are seen as the most intellectually superior in europe. Because of optimal genetic difference in mixing. Race mixing with near races (Germanics and Celtics and Baltics) produces superior breeds such as Fins for example. Breeding between humans favours this as OPTIMAL genetic difference. If not the danish race being supreme it would have to be the scotts or the japs.
I didnt know the scotts were that germanic and if they are thats terrifying because they have the same neanderthal gene that the ashkenazis have that gives them a fucked up long skull and hence why they invented so much shit despite making up 10% of the british population the gene is what also makes them ugly ofc.
It's been known for a while but for whatever reason they seem hellbent on persisting with their celt0id LARP. Quite saddening, really, nothing more pathetic than a people completely cucked to an ethnolinguistic group they objectively do not belong to. Here's a population density map of Scotland. As you can see almost the entire population of the region lives within the 40-60% range.
Scotland is officially more 'genetically Germanic' than Austria is.
Why dont you fucking show your flag? Secondly this is what a Yas Forums thread is supposed to be like. Covid19 shit belongs on /news/. The rest of the threads are basically /bant/. Scotland is a victim of anti-imperialst libertarian bullshit from hollywood. Im like 30% scottish and we accomplished so much when we were actually living under a right wing tyranny now we are reduced to a welfare state apparently. Im actually scottish royalty and anglican british so i got a fair chance of that castle.
Why does my flag matter I already said where I'm from.
Landon Bailey
I really wish Cromwell had made the Commonwealth of England a permanent thing. Celtic identity needs to be expunged from the British Isles. Scotland is English and Germanic in the exact same sense Austria is German and Germanic.
Is Mohammed Jabar a Scot as well then? The guy is clearly of Anglo-Saxon descent like a huge percentage of Scotland is. His name is from Old English and its a habitational name from one of the most Germanic parts of the British Isles, southeast Scotland. Roxburghshire to be exact.
>Maxwell is a Scottish surname and is a habitational name derived from a location near Melrose, in Roxburghshire, Scotland. This name was first recorded in 1144, as Mackeswell, meaning "Mack's spring (or stream)" (from the Old English well[a]).
The Scottish were/are the Gaels.
What's your point the majority of them descend from the colonists, not the other way around.
Ayden Sanders
>Maxwell is a Scottish surname and is a habitational name derived from a location in Roxburghshire, Scotland. This name was first recorded in 1144, as Mackeswell, meaning "Mack's spring (or stream)" (from the Old English well[a]).
Zachary Thomas
No. read.
That blood needs to keep rolling for selective purposes. We just need more germanics in europe. Celts tend to have wide skulls. To be honest Celts are to Germanics what Goats are to Sheep. Celts dont follow instructions function in society so i guess that makes them our jews. Remember the key point. Germano-celts are superior to germanics. But germanics are the supreme pure phenotype.
Btw basically every famous inventor and individual people constantly laud as Scottish also has a clearly Germanic last name coming from English or other Germanic languages.
Watt, Baird, Bell, Fleming, Telford, Anderson, Muir etc. etc. etc.
Almost any great person to come out of Scotland was ultimately of Germanic descent for the most part.
Jason Watson
I said the identity needs to be expunged, not their genes. Their genes aren't even Celtic anyway, L21 doesn't cluster with Celts at all, it clusters most closely by far with Germanic peoples and they spread into the British Isles from the Rhineland originally.
We cannot allow subversive nations within nations nigger tier mentality. It is parasitic and divisive. The "Celts" of the British Isles must be completely assimilated and integrated into an English and Germanic identity just as the non-Germanic peoples in Austria and other places were.
Isaiah Campbell
>muh genes >muh my ancestor was a fish
go back and kys
Eli Morris
Show flag, fenian
Angel Robinson
Activities in life dont increase your IQ. Im athiest aswell but the term means nothing nowadays. Morons like you think your nicholas copernicus coming forth as an athiest in 2020. I remember when athiests used to be smart. It doesnt matter what you think or how much facts you know. Your brain opperates at the same voltage as it did before you knew the facts. Intellect is a measurement of processing power and creativity. You are an atheist without an advanced physics degree. You are nothing. Kill yourself.
And you're only about 70% R1b-L21.Which isn't even genetically Celtic you fucking retard. You were literally just conquered and assimilate by continental Celts in prehistory with barely any genetic input.
It's not the English who are barely Germanic. It's YOU who are literally not Celtic in any way, shape or form.
But then you're too fucking stupid and/or disingenous being the snivelling little fenian maggot you are to acknowledge that, aren't you. Subhuman filth.
Leo Diaz
>They are Germanic but barely Germanic.
Is Austria barely Germanic? Are Bavarians barely Germanic?
Thomas Hughes
Fuck by your own stupid fucking logic half of Germany isn't even Germanic you retarded fucking twat. Why are you so incredibly stupid you little fucking parasite?
Again, R1b-L21 literally is not Celtic. It does not cluster with Celts. It never clustered with Celts in places like Iberia and elsewhere. The latest genetics studies have all overwhelmingly shown R1b-L21 clusters most closely (BY FAR) with Germanic peoples.
You were literally Corded Ware offshoots who got conquered and assimilated by Celts in prehistory. Your entire fucking identity has been swapping one form of cuckoldry for another.
Owen Hall
>I'm from Scotland and consider myself to be Germanic and merely a regional subgroup of English i.e. totally kek'd by anglos
Jason Allen
The 'Celts' will be around long after the English are gone. English identity doesn't exist any more. In a couple of generations all of england will comprise of afro-pakistani rape babies.
Nolan Bailey
You’re all pathologically obsessed with haplogroups and shit that doesn’t affect your life to even the slightest degree. If you’re “pure germanic stock” but accomplish fuck all but jerking off to anime tiddies and posting on Yas Forums, is that something to be proud of...? I’m not arguing against ethnonationalism at all btw, just this neurotic obsession shared by so many brainlets on this board >inb4 amerimutt Sure whatever
Carter Wilson
>i.e. totally kek'd by anglos
The region is over 50% descended from Germanic peoples, and the rest all speak a Germanic tongue natively. How is it fucking cuckoldry to identify as what you fucking are, retard?
Where are you from you little fucking pedophile.
Jace Adams
>In a couple of generations all of england will comprise of afro-pakistani rape babies.
Eyyyyyy Ireland isn't the same. Ahahahahahahahahahhahaha! Considering how fucking poor, ugly and stupid the average R1b-L21 is you're going to get absolutely bred out of existence with more competition in fucking a single generation.
you're fucking hysterical, truly you are. And R1b-L21 IS NOT FUCKING CELTIC. WHY ARE YOU NOT UNDERSTANDING THAT, LITTLE BUDDY?
Jordan Richardson
>Where are you from you little fucking pedophile does the truth hurt that bad, bitch boy?
Noah Ross
Basically people don't understand haplogroups, don't understand history, don't understand genetics and are far too prone to dive head first into the sea of anachronism. That's basically the gist of it.
Robert Bailey
What fucking truth? You're made a statement about it being cuckoldry to identify as what you objectively are in an ethnolinguistic sense, retard. How the fuck can that register in your alcohol sodden little peabrain as a victory?
why does it bother you that people enjoy discussing this stuff? haplomemes are basic bitch HBD stuff that any autist can easily latch onto as babby's first foray into a sea of redpills.
>R1b-L21 IS NOT FUCKING CELTIC no haplomeme belongs to any one specific ethnic group, but L21 is celtic as shit when compared to other branches of r1b and I1
Yeah, the cuck is the one who natively speaks English, has an English name, looks like other English people and is genetically identical as them identifying as English and Germanic.
As opposed to you, probably all the exact same things as me but identifying as Gaelic Celts (which itself is a fucking cucked identity as they were only Celtic through being conquered and assimilated anyway) and prostrating yourself for them at every turn you little pedophilic freak.
Also Celtic identity is literally revisionist meme tier Wakandan nationalism victim mentality egalitarian hyperlefist cringefest anyway so enjoy you fucking roaster.
Does your boyfriend have blue hair too you silly little embarrassing cunt?
Owen Jackson
your little foul-mouthed temper tantrum is perfect evidence in support of the FACT that you are scotch untermensch. keep thrashing, goy
Caleb Watson
>but L21 is celtic as shit when compared to other branches of r1b and I1
No it's not at all. It doesn't cluster with other Celts, at all. It clusters by far most closely with Germanic people. Why don't you understand genetics? Do you want me to link you the studies showing the inhabitants of the British Isles pre-Germanic invasions were genetically Corded Ware? Do you know what Corded Ware is? Do you know what it means if L21 descends from them and isn't actually genetically Beaker?
Is it going to actually change your opinion? Will you concede when I show you that or are you going to continue burying your head in the sand LARPing as some fantasy identity you don't belong to in order to feel like a special little snowflake
I wish instead of numbers they used meaningful names like "blue eyed cunts".
Carter Robinson
>but L21 is celtic as shit when compared to other branches of r1b and I1
>Recent genetic studies have suggested that Britain's Neolithic population was largely replaced by a population from North Continental Europe characterised by the Bell Beaker culture around 1200 BC, associated with the Yamnaya people from the Pontic-Caspian Steppe. This population lacked genetic affinity to other Bell Beaker populations, such as the Iberian Bell Beakers, but appeared to be an offshoot of the Corded Ware single grave people.[34][35] It is currently unknown whether these Beaker peoples went on to develop Celtic languages in the British Isles, or whether later Celtic migrations introduced Celtic languages to Britain.[36]
>The close genetic affinity of these Beaker people to Continental North Europeans means that British and Irish populations cluster genetically very closely with other Northwest European populations, regardless of how much Anglo-Saxon and Viking ancestry was introduced during the 1st millennium.
Do you understand this, mate? Do you need me to explain it in detail to you?
Adrian Cook
english, celts = germans
picts = us who live here and aren't germans
Xavier Myers
>no haplomeme belongs to any one specific ethnic group,
Celtic isn't an ethnic group it's an ethnolinguistic group. One that almost nobody in the British Isles belongs to anymore. They at least partially belonged to it (in the same way western Turks are Turkic despite not really being genetically) when Ireland and Wales still spoke Celtic tongues, but almost nobody does there anymore. So there's literally nothing Celtic about them anymore. They're about as Celtic as Ashkenazi converts with Hebrew names are.
Germanic isn't an ethnic group it's an ethnolinguistic group. One that almost all indigenous peoples of the British Isles belong to regardless of what they claim to be politically or ethnically or nationally.
If you speak a Germanic language, have a Germanic name and are white you are Germanic. That's the way it's always been. Language, name and phenotype.
The genes merely bolster the Germanicness of the British Isles people. As not only do they speak a Germanic language and have Germanic names, the people they are closest to genetically, by far, are other Germanic peoples.
Thus they are part of the Germanic ethnolinguistic group, objectively.
Austin Harris
>picts = us who live here and aren't germans
Absolutely none of the people in the British Isles do not come from Germany. Even the people there before the Germanic invasions literally came from the Rhineland. That's where R1b-L21 is traced back to, the Rhineland, and that's your oldest haplogroup by far.
All the rest are either Germanic or in far smaller numbers Italic.
Christian Campbell
Thanks for your levelheaded answer, fellow Germanibro.
Oliver Hernandez
The cut off is pretty hard, do you not gangrape the welsh?
Aiden Foster
I would like you to take a deep breath and explain to me, without using reddit spacing, exactly why you feel the need to so aggressively assert Britain's Germanicism. If we were to compare the accomplishments of the Anglosphere to those of the other Germanic countries, the others don't even compare. This being the case, why cling to Germanicism so aggressively? I don't even disagree with you, but the English speaking world can stand on its own perfectly fine.
t. Anglo-burger with a Brittonic Scottish last name and L21 as my haplomeme
>he thinks Picts were indo-european
Owen Brown
See Offa's Dyke. For whatever reason we just penned them into barren land for 1500 years instead and used them as cannon fodder. Also the Welsh did some colonizing of their own in Ireland as we spread into there under our new Norman overlords. I believe Walsh (obviously meaning Welsh) is like the 4th most common surname in all of Ireland.
Btw is this an issue in Germany. Are Bavarians and Baden-Württembergers seen as non-Germanic due to their comparitively lower levels of Germanic descent?
What about Austrians? I thought most were pretty adamant Austrians were fellow Germans for most of history. How can this be the case when they're significantly less Germanic than Scotland is?
Seems like you Germans just consider it to be a language, name and phenotype thing. But maybe I'm wrong.
Tyler Walker
It's nice to be part of a larger family and know where you come from. I'm well aware the English world can stand on its own, but knowing the history of our people going all the way back to the Proto-Germanic homelands of northern Germany and southern Scandinavia is a beautiful thing.
As is reading about all the similarly descended peoples like the Franks, the Goths and others who disappeared through assimilation and mingling into other groups.
Jaxson Ward
Bitch boy? Fucking wigga
Gabriel Sanders
This is as dumb as saying white Americans were colonised by Europeans.
Brody Perry
fucking island monkeys
William Torres
Use the correct term, my friend. It's a beautiful one, so use it.
Inselaffen
Bentley Baker
Of course. The original "germanic" areas are North Germany, Netherlands and southern Scandinavia. These people are direct descendants of proto germanic tribes. The further away you are from that the less "ethnically germanic" things get even if people there belong to a Germanic culture and speak a Germanic language. German speaking inhabitants of the Alps are mostly Germanized Celts. So are the English. Germans east of the Elbe are to a degree germanized Slavs and Balts (back when east prussia was still a thing). Just because you speak a Germanic language doesent mean you "are Germanic".
