Why isn't Madoka considered one of the best anime anymore?

Why isn't Madoka considered one of the best anime anymore?

Attached: Screenshot_2020-04-12 Anime Top 50 Best Rated (bayesian estimate) - Anime News Network.png (777x718, 44.77K)

>Clannad AS
>Code Geass
>Haruhi
>Death Note
It seems that ANN has not changed tastes, unlike MAL. I don't know if this is good.

I always hated Madoka, but I've been told by a friend of mine that rewatching Madoka made him like the show significantly less since it's primarily appeal are shock value and twist.

>Madoka
>Best anime
Pick one

> The list when you remove the Shonen shit is this
> 1. Your Name
> 2. Steins Gate
> 3. Clannad AS
> 4. Spirited Away
> 5. Mushishi
> 6. Bebop
> 7. Mononoke
> 8. Silent Voice
> 9. Disappearence
> 10. LoGH
> 11. Mada in Abyss
> 12. MariMite S3
> 13. MariMite S2
> 14. Anohana
> 15. MariMite S2
> 16. Decending Stories
> 17. Bunny Drop

Does each season of MariMite really need to take up a separate slot in this list?

Rebellion really ruined the original series

Agreed

Also, Magia Record

all these lists and I will nevee give a shit about FMA:Generichood

i fucking hate all the shilling this crap gets, obnoxious.

Rebellion ruined it, also other everyone jumped on the Symphogear bandwagon after XV

Nice normalfag core MAL tier list

Filtered hard

> Waaah Filtered
Tranny
> MariMite
> Normalfag core
Retard

lists have always been composed of shit opinions from casuals. You included OP. You can't even explain why madoka should be anywhere near the top without decent reasons.

Time flop, artificially kept alive by autistic trannies.

Attached: unnamed (1).jpg (362x512, 64K)

Explain right now how MariMite is mainstream popular

>Your Name
Lmao

I watched it on a lark. It was good but nothing extraordinary

why is maria watches over us in this list

>reddit and inferior to 2003
>reddit
>reddit
>trash
>decent, but not worthy of top 25
>R2 lmao
>overrated, but still top 25
>reddit
>Yas Forums
>overrated, but still top 25
>no opinion
>overrated, but still top 25
>okay, but maybe 1/4th of people that voted for this have actually watched it
>reddit
>trash
>reddit
>why
>why
>okay
>yes
>how is this so high on a normalfag list?
>decent but not worthy of top 25
>why

feel free to like comment and subscribe

It never was, only /u/ tourists and ironic retards pretend to like it.

Yas Forums was obsessed with madoka in 2011 all the way until at least 2013 when KLK became the next biggest c/a/ncer.
It may belong on le wall of not so cool any more fanbases I was a part of, but to deny at least one page of the catalog was madoka threads at any given time is disingenuous.

Cry more

>anohana is good
Opinions discarded

>Maria watches over us
Who?

Next you're going to tell me stories about how Yas Forums only pretended to like Code Geass, or Gurren Lagann, or all those other anime you were definitely on Yas Forums to see airing.

try harder

This poster is a homosexual

I actually regret using >yes instead of >okay for this one. I could see anohana being around 30th place or so in a personal list of post 2000 anime for me.

What in particular do you disagree with? I'm genuinely not trolling with any of those answers. I haven't seen "a silent voice" or even seen it discussed on Yas Forums so I cannot comment. It's probably reddit or normalfag femshit since Yas Forums doesn't talk about it.

The logic is that FMA was one of the greatest anime of all time, but they created Brotherhood anyway, and that would only make sense if brotherhood was better than FMA, so natually brotherhood would have to be better than FMA and take its place.

But it turns out the only good parts of Brotherhood are the parts that you go back and find out were actually from FMA.

Magia Record has tarnished it's name

In that case we can put it up there with nanoha and code geass and literally every other fotm shonen from "the time when Yas Forums was better".

Zoomer subhuman

>anymore

Because Homura ruined everything.