Got this list almost a decade ago

>got this list almost a decade ago
does it hold up Yas Forums? What would you add and what would you remove?

Attached: 1295166682968.jpg (1460x2350, 1.67M)

Decent enough list for people starting off

>recommending SEED
Would probably swap for Turn A or Wing.

Other than that, pretty good list

I'd change some stuff in the SoL, Drama, and Sports category, but overall this still seems fine for a beginner.

It’s still good. Just remember that it’s for people who don’t know what they like in anime.

Personally I prefer the bait one where half the shows don't even exist

Add this

Attached: 1578367598517.jpg (1280x720, 73.81K)

I would also add ACCA 13, chihayfuru, tsukigakirei

Add this into Comedy, contender for anime of last decade

Attached: He's a dandy guy, in space.jpg (1280x720, 185.12K)

Seeing GTO in the same category as Kamichu and Sketchbook is a bit odd

a decade ago, I would have removed a 3/4 of that list . What a shit list
holy shit

bebop isn't action imo

I would just add rows to the bottom, desu.
I don't care that it would intimidate newfags, I like BIG lists

Attached: all of the slashaslash recommended anime charts.jpg (3380x3622, 2.91M)

This list got some update work done in 2015, but the work was never finished.

The original has some really questionable choices like Air.

Attached: 1451301101212.jpg (1580x2350, 1.81M)

>hunterxhunter
>adventure
>being on the list at all
Better stick to the previous version. This one has too much 2010s garbage.

Also I began working, or at least thinking and organizing for working on, an updated and completely reworked version.
However, I got really stuck on the low number of 2010s anime compared to the 2000s anime, which probably means there are some biases still. Anime wasn't that much better in the 2000s, right? Which means that the standards for a recent anime to be included end up being higher than for older anime.

Don't pay too much attention to the specifics of the genres, especially creativity seems like it's impossible to do well. But the greater idea is to have more genres and fewer anime in each genre.

Attached: Chart work.png (1785x728, 953.74K)

Anime is a dying industry so yeah, there is likely to be more quality content in earlier decades.

>However, I got really stuck on the low number of 2010s anime compared to the 2000s anime
At least for the CGDCT one it should be mostly from the 2010s. Even with Hidamari the best seasons were in the 10s.

Attached: 1422651361876.gif (346x360, 872.63K)

Decided could as well show off all I've done so far.
Also have Yuru Camp but haven't put it in a folder yet because I'm not sure about genre.

Attached: Rec chart wip.png (1520x3796, 3.92M)

I much prefer lists which avoid classifying things into only one genre. As you yourself have noticed, things can quickly get difficult. Personally one of the better lists I have seen is pic related. Short sentence about the content, short sentence on a meta level, rough genre categorization, rough attempt to gauge four common factors (romance, comedy, action, drama), illustrative picture, number of episodes, year of release. And finally, there are only 50 entries. For a "before you ask for recommendations" list, there is no need to have 200 entries. It's much more effective to actually present fewer series than to dump a fucton of names.

Attached: wSUUdJ.jpg (1925x4653, 3.37M)

It's not only about "before you ask for recommendations", I also just like to use a chart when watching anime, and see how much I can cross out and work my way through the most important anime with a specific goal.
For this purpose, there's nothing wrong with having 200 entries.

Yeah, genres can be tricky. But it's also a way to try to enforce your personal ideas about genre classifications, if your list gets popular you gain power.
AND, it's like the greater overall list as well, trying to work your way through a certain subset of anime, like see how much you can watch of a specific genre.
And it's fun to work on, it's like a puzzle trying to find 10 of each genre while including all that's important.

Right, that's a completely different motivation. I understand, personally I find great joy in going through 2chs yearly popularity ranking and crossing off what I have seen.

Attached: Anime years.jpg (2465x3517, 3.98M)

Wing is the only series worse than Seed

00s was the best decade for anime. Not the best looking decade for sure, arguably the worst animation since the 70s, but the aesthetics were top notch a lot of the time and art had a ton of soul. It was a decade of experimentation and exploration. All kinds of shows, with the wildest and most interesting premises were made in 00. In comparison, 10s anime is very safe and mass produced. Just mostly clones of the same thing over and over. Every production committee is only concerned with shilling their manga, novel, video game or some other product. Thing is, streaming actually pays enough now to cover the costs of production so it's virtually impossible to lose money on anime nowadays. You'd think studios would be jumping at the opportunity to finally make some interesting anime but they're just going through the motions and simply producing what they're contracted to produce like wageslaves.

>no gintama

Actually finished it a while back and never posted it.

And the original had too much 2000s garbage on it since it was made 2008.

Attached: chart.jpg (1580x2350, 1.2M)

Thank you! But did you actually cut Toradora for Kimagure Orange Road...
Can't find Code Geass either

That's pretty decent.

>00's garbage
opinion discarded.

I guess this is a good opportunity to ask for help with I'm almost done with mecha, don't think there are many things that need changing, but.
Real Robot has 4 different Gundams. 3 of them were on the previous chart, and Gundam Unicorn was added by me. But it's a bit random that I chose that Gundam over any of the other popular recents.
This also assumes that there are no other worthwhile real robot series made.
Is Gundam Unicorn the real robot that should be chosen?

Super Robot was to somewhat big extent based on a discussion I had on Yas Forums about how to organize mecha, where I speculated on creating an own Gundam genre, and many of the choices are taken from that person's suggestions.
I think it seems okay. Due to quotas for different time periods, SSSS Gridman was chosen. Time quotas was also what made Zambot 3 be the chosen anime, over his other suggestions.
I'm pretty happy with the Super Robot part, it feels finished and I can't see any need for major changes.

Drama: would like more slots, but may do with what I have

Action: Just throw stuff that don't fit elsewhere.

Have doubts about Dragon Ball. It may get in on historical importance, but maybe soem of the generic modern battle shounen are more deserving.

I have a strong feeling Dr Stone deserves to be in, but no idea where to place it.

Space Opera were cut somewhat randomly because I haven't seen much, Knights of Sidonia is in on time of release quotas and CGI quotas, but not actually sure if it's space opera.

Not sure how much I should ramble. Know very little about Nana, maybe it could fit in Drama instead of romance? same with honey and clover, no idea because I haven't seen them.

I guess I should just believe and though that modern anime is garbage compared to 2000s anime and not worry so much

Is this custom made or is there a website for it making such lists? I like the genre breakdown better here, like on anilist, instead of a single genre tag, because most of the time stories are multilayered and represent multiple genres.

I'm about 95 % sure this is custom made. It was made by a guy called PixelPenguins, so if you google the name then maybe he has commented somewhere regarding the creation process.

post it

>Before you make a recommendation thread on Yas Forums
>recommendation thread on Yas Forums
You're already starting it wrong.

It's tradition.
Recommendation threads probably used to be accepted if effort was put into it

>Haruhi in comedy
>Not sci-fi or psychological
>Not even SoL or romance (at least the mistake would have been understandable)
>Fucking comedy
Not even reading the rest. It's garbage.

Attached: bruh.jpg (300x450, 29.98K)

It can be justified with it being sort of a meta parody of sci-fi tropes, but I agree that comedy isn't the best fit.

Parody doesn't necessarily imply comedy, though. It's like saying Madoka is a comedy because it "parodies" magical girl shows.
Yes, Haruhi has jokes and funny stuff in it, but like, even NGE does. If that's enough to fall under comedy then fuck me lmao

I don't think Madoka is a parody in the same way. And I feel that parody does imply comedy.

best version so far. wish it had at least a super robot show. maybe replace ms team since gundam is over represented. also wish yawara was there in the sports genre. I'd swap it for akaji since I wouldn't really recommend it, to beginners or otherwise

there you go fuccboi

Attached: 1580847262546.png (2350x4700, 3.61M)

Then Haruhi wouldn't be a parody either, more like a deconstruction.

I disagree, I think part of it is that people are meant to see things they are familiar with done in a self aware way and they are meant to laugh to themselves at seeing the familiar tropes done like this.
Or something.
Personally I don't have much experience with what Haruhi parodies.

This is a pretty good selection, I was about to complain about the lack of Dezaki in the original one. I'd also add Noir under action, and OKG under mecha, and if Macross Frontier and Psycho Pass made the cut, Space Dandy probably should do as well. Not sure what would I cut out, though.

The main point of Haruhi is that it has fictional elements integrated in a logical and realistic way. At the beginning Kyon complais fictional elements can't possibly exist because of how well the rules of the universe are written, but then he gets completely proved wrong by fictional elements poping up in front of him while actually making sense. That's why it has a perfect representation of time travel that doesn't contradict causality, why its "god" figure (Haruhi) plays the role of the "designer" of a predetermined universe instead of being just symbolism and bible references, why aliens are handled in a way that makes sense too (the Data Overmind could be seen as a in-universe application of the concept of Laplace's demon), and why overall these elements bend into reality perfectly.
As i said yes, it has its funny side, but if you think that's all the show is about you really didn't understand shit.

Attached: 1567029053808.jpg (1850x2151, 1.75M)

I've never thought that deeply into Haruhi, but you're porbably right, and I always agreed with you that it'd fit better into Sci-fi. When you explain it like this it sounds more like something Madoka esque than just a regular parody.

That list is trash, try these instead

Attached: 1980s anime rec chart.jpg (1836x3405, 2.3M)

Looking at this list was a trip down memory lane.

Attached: 1990s anime rec chart.jpg (1836x3405, 2.31M)

He was talking about the one that was mostly shows inside other shows like Gekiganger3 and Pooki

Attached: 2000s anime rec chart.jpg (1836x3405, 2.3M)

>Garzey's Wing

Attached: 1513548863585.png (600x600, 399.9K)

Attached: 2010s anime rec chart.jpg (1836x3405, 2.34M)

>DBGT
kek

>Nichijou
>Instead of Nichibros

This is very outdated. Def not for starters but for people who've watched all the decent newer stuff and now watch to check out some oldies.

Are they similar in other ways than name? There's a chance it may be one of the next 200 anime I watch, but if it's similar to Nichijou I may push it further down my list.

>Disliking 00's
Fuck off buddy.

This
1995 to 2011 was the peak