Raildex

Was Kamachi during World Rejector arc a misunderstood genius or a talentless hack?

Attached: Shinyaku_Toaru_Majutsu_no_Index_Light_Novel_v14_cover.jpg (700x1000, 134.86K)

What kind of OP is this?

Touma didn't do anything wrong.

Attached: It's fucking rape.jpg (1518x1000, 228.51K)

World Rejector arc was a pleb filter. Also shit OP, kill yourself

He was always hack, albeit a decent one, who wrote some portions quite well.

>But Kamijou had been wrong
>Kamisato’s way had been right.
They hated him because he told the truth

Attached: 1492113777096.jpg (452x526, 38.58K)

>he was always a hack, which is why I read over 40 volumes of his work and obsessively post in threads related to his work
I love this meme so much

Hey, I did say he writes some portions quite well. But overall I don't feel it amounts to much, his writing has glaring enough flaws from me call him a hack. And you don't have to agree with me if you don't feel the same way.

god I wish I were Mikoto

Attached: [HorribleSubs] Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T - 07 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_17.32_[2020.03.28_03.53.28].jpg (1920x1080, 304.5K)

Kamisato arc was Lola's deliberate attempt to completely derail the current narrative and mess up Aleister's plan beyond repair, interrupting story flow as a result.
In other words, kino

He's an idiot savant, WR just happened to be 80/20 at best.

We need Aleister back, his planned happenings are way more fun than Coronzon's disrupted happenings. Can accelerator even come close to manipulate the world to make fun adventures for Touma to get into?

If he's not dead then he's obviously coming back.

You've got Aiwass for that now

Touma is black pilled now, no more fun and games now only tears and sufferng

He's kubo tier

Attached: 1581110319129.png (333x500, 172.73K)

Why?

Who failed harder at protecting a loli, Kakine or Beetle?

You know, if anything this means Touma is actually in danger of getting heavily fucked up since Crowley isnt there to protect him with AC nanotech

Kakine since his loli fucking died

He did everything wrong.
That’s the second best thing about him.

Attached: 1562865340978.jpg (859x906, 82.17K)

>AC nanotech
What about all the time he's outside AC then?

World Rejector was the buildup arc for the Aleister arc.

>Since when were you in the impression that Level 5s went from 1 to 7

Attached: 32rhizarmfp41.jpg (2480x1748, 3.33M)

That's bad. Then again Bleach had some really hype moments.

Attached: 0ydjx5sv6fp41.jpg (1624x2048, 310.99K)

Wheres the metal butt?

The MisaMisa headbump was really cute, but would have been cuter if their faces bumped into each other and almost accidentally kissed instead

Nice

Wouldn't it be even more cute if they accidentally fucked?

Attached: EUIMHHmWsAIkkFn.jpg (1920x1080, 168.89K)

>Wouldn't it be even more cute if they accidentally fucked?
I thought Kamachi was based. How come something like this still hasn't happened?

Mikoto already took her virginity in NT21 with the AAA

He was the best shitposter these threads have ever seen.

A genius as always. WR Arc was great.

Kamachi a hack. A HACK.

Because he isn't a Lesbiantard. Hope that guy was killed off last thread.

Nah. If Kubo didn't get sick for the last 5 years of his serialization, TYBW would have been an amazing finish. He definitely writes similar to Kubo in how he does twists.

>Has Misaki and Mikoto come almost kiss in SS3
>Has their lips come less than 5 cm away in NT18, has Mikoto touch Misaki's lips.
>Play Footsies
>Have them feed each others
>Misaki frequently runs her finger down Mikoto's spine.
Kamachi really loves Yuribait, you can't deny that.

Kamisato arc is hindsight was pretty good. The anti harem bits were great. His interactions with touma were good. The arc also did a lot to setup Mikoto. Honestly the only real problem is that NT 16 feels kinda unnecessary Yuitsu is shit. Yuitsu still has world rejector by the end, Mikoto is running with a self made AAA that she pretty much drops by the next volume, and it really just feels like an excuse for everyone to have swimsuits. Yuitsu wasn't really all that interesting, she was a noukan fangirl that got mad when he got hurt. She started into that spreading kihara stuff at the end but nothing came of it thus far. Her problem is that she loaded so much shit into her stock that a lot of it felt underutilized. Like the element AAA that got destroyed in two seconds, or how she stopped using WR after NT15. Then there is the saint germaine pill which was so pointless that kamachi re-purposed the scene Anna. Should have just left it as an explanation on how she used magic and WR.

(I know he does I just like being a dick)

>and it really just feels like an excuse for everyone to have swimsuits.
And this is why Kamachi is a genius. Swimsuit apocalypse in December is a great idea.

>and it really just feels like an excuse for everyone to have swimsuits
That's what he said. Js06 translated an interview and Kamachi straight up said the heatwave was primarily because he wanted to see the characters in swimsuits.

Gotta disagree on Yuiitsu. I really enjoyed her because this was one of the few times we get to see an antagonist grow throughout and what exactly entails turning into a full fledged Kihara. Also, the use of St Germain was a nice link to NT12 and Anna. It's pretty obvious he's not done with it.

NT16 was for Tokiwadai being destroyed

She felt wasted on NT17

Nah. It's a lingering plot point and she did her job in corrupting them which was pointed out. This was made obvious.

>The anti harem bits were great
The problem is that after the first volume with them, they stopped being a parallel with Touma and were played straight for the next three. God it was fucking obnoxious. You're also right, everything it set up amounted to nothing or got dropped. I would not call it "good" collectively

Kamachi handles shounen differently (and usually better) than most writers but WR arc was when he stooped down to their levels with asspulls and abhorrent new characters.
Thankfully the "experiment" ended and he got his groove back with the Aleister arc.

She did nothing but be a moustache twirling villian and sit on Salome, she should have had more agency on getting rid of Touma

>literally maidono last volume
Fuck.

>asspulls
Kamachi does it more frequently than most Shounen writers.

Kamisato didn't stop being anti harem until NT17

O MY BROKEN GLASS

O MY BLACK WINGS
O MY AAA
O MY DRAGONS

What about her?

O MY THIRD TREE
Fucking accelerator.

That glass inputting launch codes cracks me up as hell. I still can't believe he wrote it with a straight face.

The dragons are probably the most well set up thing in the series.

She was quite literally that, in the fact the only real reason she's not level five is it would make magic nations go full retard and declare war.

It's the worst arc in the entire series that made me drop NT for 2 years.

It was trash. You can argue ice boats was also shit but it didn't last so fucking long.

>appear once in OT2
>next time they appear chronologically it's in a fucking spinoff where they won't be explored properly

Attached: 1498351198036.jpg (640x640, 67.49K)

OT9-11 is objectively worse and almost as long

It's ok user it's back to being fun again and Touma may or may not be on QUAD BRAIN DAMAGE now.

If Misaka hadn't received the AAA under such pressure and that emergency situation, she wouldn't have become so heavily dependent on it and used it constantly despite the burden. The AAA thing was actually well thought out.

NT11 is great.

She is not level 5 because her powers sucked.
There are plenty of level 4s that could fill the role of the 8th if they got their shit together and Maidono is not one of them.

Dragons have been foreshadowed for like 10+ volumes atleast though

>OT

Whoops, never mind.

But no OT9-11 was nowhere near as infuriating as Kamisato.

Kakine spelled it out in DM manga too. Power-output and fighting prowess aren't what determines a level 5's value.

This
Junko is more of a Level 5 than Maidono and would be the #8 if it wasnt for Rikou maybe becoming relevant

Yeah but that's the official reason, not the fact her ability is shit, not that she isn't good enough, it's because her ability if announced is the equivalent of MAD being set off.

>100.000 tons

She's way better than Mugino. Her power is completely insane. She obliterated Misaka with no real effort.

see

And yet Mugino is lv5 when all she can do is beams.

Yeah, it was like a dose of instant relief, that she finally managed to save Touma and saw a possibility of climbing onto his stage. NT13 and NT15 built-up her mindset by constantly taking mental beating at not having enough power, AAA under any other circumstances I think she would have kept her distance, in fact she was so reluctant in NT15 itself.

>not sure if the dragon even exists
>confirms some fuckery is going on in there with Fiamma and several things in there
>has different outputs as shown with Othinus
>confirms they form as visible dragons in AC by Daihaseisai
>all the shit with the Kamisato and Aleister arcs
Seems solid to me as far as showing it off and giving little hints. Frustrating yes, asspull no.

Kekine can't even save a single loli, he has no authority in shit.

She can control the electron state and violates the uncertainty principle at will

>She obliterated Misaka with no real effort
No she didn't.

Mugino's ability to destabilize electrons is far more impressive both from a research and combat point of view than anything Maidono could ever do.

Yes she did. Without Touma appearing Misaka would be smashed like a bug.

By that logic Frenda and Hamazura are level 5 too

>lifting 100,000 tons with no effort is nothing
>flying aircraft carriers are nothing
>being able to move buildings is nothing

Show me a single useful AC tech developed from Mugino.

Read:
You can say whatever bullshit you want, but she's close enough that they legit considered to put her in level 5 tier and there's a different reason why she's not.

Based Aleister.
Not mention the name of the one who purfies God and slays demons was dropped in OT1. That's one hell of a foreshadowing.

Attached: 666.jpg (320x456, 42.03K)

That's not the same things as obliterating her. This wasn't a fair match for Mikoto to begin with who had zero intel on Maidono, also Mikoto's own moralfag mentality worked against her, it was a very situational fight.

Aleister BTFOing Lola, as expected

It kinda feels like all the bad parts of the AAA are easily solved.
>Mikoto gets nose bleeds
>just builds a compatible AAA
>there is a heavy strain when using AAA
>just split the burden with misaki and neither seem to have any problems with it since
>hijacks
>all the hijackers went away

Then you're skipping a lot of detail. She literally physically abused the girls and shat on them to a breaking point throughout the entire novel. Touma really wasn't her obsession after all as she pointed out what her end goal is regarding being a Kihara is like. This isn't rocket science.

I'm expecting a fallout between Mikoto and Misaki, since Misaki might not be willing anymore after NT22R. I think this is the calm before the storm.

O MY MAGIC GODS

>introduces over a dozen new characters in NT21
The only experiment was the broken hearted Fran, the rest is similar