ITT: Great manga with horrible adaptations
ITT: Great manga with horrible adaptations
Elijah Williams
Connor Rodriguez
but the bakuman anime not only is equal but also objectively superior to the manga
Daniel Stewart
I dropped this once they started serializing.
Cooper Cruz
>equal
>objectively superior
tripfags are so fucking retarded jesus christ
Parker Ramirez
they cut out one of the best characters for absolutely no reason
Jack Bailey
I'm reading this literally right now, being a story about manga it made sense to go for the manga instead of the anime from the begining. But i might check the anime if i end up liking the whole thing enough.
Parker Bennett
you gonna start, op?
Justin Murphy
Alright, Twin Star Exorcists isn't exactly a great manga, but it's fairly solid and Pierrot butchered it with their anime version.
Carter Parker
easy
Hunter Turner
Obata's art was very expressive and the anime did little to capture that
Death note could get away with that because it was "mostly" a serious story
But that's not the case with bakuman, so why bother even making an adaptation in the first place
also they fucking cut out Shizuka why the fuck did they cut out Shizuka
Bentley Scott
This isn't really fair considering toei was handling it.
Christopher Ortiz
Jeremiah Cox
its not just the toei standard bad animation though they also cut a lot out
John Cooper
Cut some shit, but gave us the Super Hero Legends intro. I think it's a good trade.
Dominic Rivera
I'll admit, i did love the otter no. 11 intro they did, but cutting out shizuka just feels like a war crime
Zachary Campbell
One Piece, anything done by Toeifags.
Thomas Gutierrez
Literally every manga in existence except Shingeki no Kyojin and Gintama.
John Miller
I liked the anime
Mason Perry
the adaptation cant be worse than such a mediocre manga.
Jackson Sanchez
Who was this again? I completely forgot.
Kayden Martinez
shizuka
Tyler Perry
Agree.
The manga was a solid 7/10, but the adaptation was 3/10 at best. It was horribad.
Carson Thompson
A real shame it suffered the fate it was given.
Aaron Bell
this is every anime adaptation
Evan Cooper
It was just a neutered cheap knock-off version of comic party anyways
Adam Ramirez
I've never heard of it
But it looks very educational so I might watch it
Jack Barnes
Nathaniel Nguyen
It is
Charles Sanchez
Samurai Deeper Kyo
Manga's quality is debatable but the anime changed so much stuff that it's practically it's own series. That and the overall quality of the anime sucked (people only remember the outtakes of the English dub).
Adam Miller
Seconding this. It was like watching a beloved friend get raped on screen.
Sebastian Rivera
lewd
Wyatt Sanders
I guess they didn't want to be called a Kenshin rip-off hence the monsters in the anime.
Zachary Gray
literally everything
Robert White
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei disagrees
Nathan Gray
beastars, ajin, houseki no kuni, kyutei dragons
anything with a cgi anime adaptation is basically ruined beyond repair. japan is 30 years behind on cg animation
Gabriel Brooks
ANY Junji Ito adaptation ends up as shit
Jace Morales
i thought gyo was alright, but definitely a step down from the manga
Isaiah Williams
Not anymore I hope
Kevin Hall
Anything netflix is involved in
Sebastian Murphy
Beastars had its own charm, which I think is the ideal situation for an adaptation. Both versions have different strengths, so it's worth watching/reading both.
Jonathan Rivera
A manga about making a manga is just about the most uncreative you can make.
>Hmmmm what should my manga be about
>oh I know, I make manga so it will be about making manga
Nathaniel Morris
If it was so uncreative you would name 10 manga that is about making manga.
Charles Gonzalez
I've only seen the anime, but I thought it was great
Austin Johnson
dog
Benjamin Miller
It hurts so much. How did they fuck up so badly?
Owen Murphy
Great manga. Anime on the other hand looks like shit. Never even tried to watch it
Ryder Brooks
Another great manga with so-so anime adaptation. They removed all of the great yakuza-related chapters and also somehow managed to ruin most of the comedy moments.
Carter Wright
Is it because of the filler?
Camden Cruz
The christian arc was pretty decent
Cameron Thomas
Jitsu wa. One of my favorite romcom manga with an absolutely butchered anime adaptation
Gabriel Morales
>Pretty much every adaptation ever
Noah Gutierrez
Every Kyoani adaptation is better than the source material.
Andrew Johnson
the fuck are you talking about nigga Jitsu Wa doesn't have an anime
Connor Walker
I dunno, airmaster looks better as an anime than a manga but they omitted a ton of stuff.
Bentley Bailey
I know there I’ve seen at least 20, but I don’t keep track of the names because it’s nauseating.
Henry King
Because the author completely dropped his subplot without resolving anything.
Justin Rogers
Aside from the horrible "romance" side-plot Bakuman was really enjoyable. I miss it.
Chase Howard
Nobody posted Eyeshield 21 yet?
Benjamin Barnes
Well you didn't even name 1, so fuck you for wasting my time.
Gabriel Peterson
>Eyeshield 21
>Good
Only the art, calling it a good manga is a stretch
Cooper Garcia
But the Eyeshield 21 anime is fine
Lincoln Ortiz
In random order:
>Disappearance Diary
>Comic Girls
>Shuukan Shounen Hachi
>Joou-sama no Eshi
>Saotome Shimai Ha Manga no Tame Nara!?
>Mangaka-san to Assistant-san to
>Genshiken
>Comic Party
>Doujin Work
>Sensei, Ore ni Kamawazu Itte Kudasai!!
I can continue, but this should really be enough
Jaxon Robinson
Filler doesn't make sense though (good enough to be world class but high school tourney opponents are tougher). It's ok if it's a fighting manga but for a sports story, it's pretty bad.