Well, now that we're finally doing this unironically, will you recognize the orc genocides?

Tolkien says that lotr is not an analogy, stop inserting your filthy ideology into the moth of a dead man

Holy shit this article is for real

i mean it is a genuine plot hole, all the races are supposed to be noble and cultured but orcs are only ever seen to be evil in anything that anyone actually bothered to read or watch

no i am not going to read the semenarilion and i don't care that sauran is actually a henchman not the big bad

I am curious for what they are hoping to accomplish with this. Won't bringing this up just risk turning people further to the right if they think their stories are under attack?

Tolkien LITERALLY says they are based on mongols

Attached: EWjrmtXU8AAcQJV.png (602x798, 329.95K)

Pretty sure even Tolkein regretted making them so one dimensional

>This poor, oppressed, literally-bred-to-be-evil victim! You disgusting privileged human fucks will take this murderous abomination to your bosom as one of your own, or so help me Tempus I will shit fire all over you!

Also, this insistence that orcs are just fantasy versions of black people leads me to think that these people believe in the same stereotypes their political enemies do, but thing the savages should be uplifted with syrupy condescension instead of disdainful condescension.

Don't want to say I told you so but...
Yas Forums is always right.

Based i kinda want to read LOTR now.

>racist against mongols
you know the mongols literally were a race that knew only war and also spread the fucking bubonic plague

if there's one group it's ok to be racist against it's the mongols

Aren't Orks literally created by LOTR-Satan to be evil henchmen? Like, they're literally Elves that have been raped and tortured into Orks.

Seems silly to complain that they are onedimensional when the plot says they were literally created by a god for one specific purpose.

he didn't say they're based on mongols
he said that their appearance is similar to mongols

Aren't these guys created out of mud in the movie?

Only the giganigger Uruk-Hai.

Mongols would be your bros if you just submit to them

it's funny that the only reason this would be a thing is because everyone secretly compares the behavior of orcs to the behavior of blacks. fucking racist lefties being faggots again because they're bored with civilized society.

In the books they are breed from orcs and Dunedain, a white celtic influenced people

why do leftists immediately think of Orcs as blacks?

Attached: hmm.png (600x600, 143.37K)

>he said that their appearance is similar to mongols

Attached: 6386797fbd5ad57149e145444ddccf36.jpg (1050x591, 60.76K)

>leftards view orcs as non-whites
Pretty sure that's racist.

>implying you submit to your bros
shut the fuck up john green, that's literally colonialism but even the europeans didn't make mountains of human skulls

I don't really care if you call something racist, it's just a trilogy of good ass movies with no niggers in them

that would be a good criticism if there were any depictions of non-whites anywhere else in the movies

Attached: 1498673262242.png (694x808, 453.7K)

Yeah, based on Mongols from the worst part of their history, at least from a European perspective. Or are we going to brush away all the rape and pillaging in the 13th Century? People died.

then you agree its racist

>I don't care if it's racist
so it's racist

Attached: 1506266115037.jpg (516x357, 32.96K)

Based on how Europeans saw invading Mongols is not the same as based on Mongols.

>Orc is the anglo saxon word for demon
>Orc is also the anglo saxon word for foreigner
Based JRR

What's so scary about the r word?
Like what's your point?

Mongols empire was pretty damn peaceful dude, especially compared to the previous alternatives. Typical salty betas complaining about everything as usual.

>orcs are just humans mutilated and corrupted to not value inherently good things, like a tree.
>trannies are just men mutilated and degenerate to not value inherently good things, like normal sexual behaviour or reproducing

Really makes you think

Attached: 1498669442419.jpg (1024x629, 105.65K)

explain orc trannies

>witnesses report the suspect as having a white face

Remember when Yas Forums made memes about pretending that orcs were black people and Tolkien was racist?

If there's only whites in the movies then how could it be racist? Comparing non-whites to orcs means you see something in the orcs that reminds you of non-whites.

>peoples
nice inglish mate

get some swedecucks on it

Attached: vitpix.jpg (400x154, 25.56K)

That's why OP said we're finally doing this unironically probably
I liked the tax ones more 2bh

u mad humanboi?

Attached: orcsnshiet.png (620x882, 429.98K)

>Mongols empire was pretty damn peaceful dude
40 million people died in the conquests and then the black plague happened you dildo

of course it's peaceful when everyone's dead you slant-eyed mong

Elves - scandis
Rohan - slavs
Gondor - french/english
Trees - italians/spaniarids (they do nothing)
Hobbits - irish

Why are people suddenly upset about things that already existed?

e.g. Apu from Simpsons

Attached: 02f.jpg (655x527, 59.37K)

Jesus christ you are all racists.

Attached: 1579903127234.gif (480x322, 1.81M)

it's a fantasy world. sorry they didn't include your precious people of color. I wonder how you feel about all black colleges? hhhhmmmmm.........

*Cries in Khwarezmian*

so how many died during alexander's conquests?

Gondor is Byzantine Empire
Rohan is Anglo-Saxons on horse
Dwarves are Jews
Hobbits are rural post-19th century Anglos

>sorry they didn't include your precious people of color
it did depict people of color, they were the orcs. It was racism.

That's grammatically correct you dweeb

Shhh. You're making too much sense.

>Goldbags