You've bet the survival of the Resistance on bad odds and put us all at risk?

>proceeds to bet her entire plan on a "one in a million move"(Thanks Rise of Skywalker)
>betting the survival of the resistance on bad odds, putting them all at risk

JJ really went out his way to Btfo Rian Johnson

Attached: Holdo-Elle.png (1306x1916, 2.83M)

>More people die as a result of Holdo's plan than Poe's
>Leia chastises Poe but praises Holdo

What did Star Wars mean by this?

>there are people on this board RIGHT NOW that haven't completely given up on Star Wars

The plan wasn't for her to use the lightspeed ram at all

The only reason her plan failed is because Poe leaked it to the enemy

No it didn't. The people on the two other Resistance ships that got destroyed were killed too, and that was apparently part of her plan.

Both of the ships that were destroyed are shown to have transports evacuating the crew to the main cruiser. The medical frigate negro even says "last of our crew has been evacuated"

>I should court marshal you, take them to the brig

You're not a fucking military, you're a bunch of guerilla fighters. Why the fuck didn't Poe tell them all to fuck off for the blatant disrespect for the only pilot worth a damn apparently in the entire group.

Are you genuinely retarded?

ever notice her plan was pretty much 9/11?

Not an argument

>don't tell leaders plan
>they ruin an otherwise fine plan because you didn't tell them the details
>>The only reason her plan failed is because Poe leaked it to the enemy

Attached: by all accounts it doesnt.jpg (1009x624, 133.17K)

One of the moral throughlines of the entire saga, which is explicitly laid out for retards in Rogue One, is that the bad guys are bad because they unquestioningly obey authority even when they know it's wrong, and the Rebels disobey authority in order to do the right thing. In that context the moral of the moral of the Holdo plotline is incomprehensible. Poe was 100% in the right and Holdo is a dumb bitch who deserved her death.

Her plan makes sense if you assume she believed that everyone who died under her command would become her servant in the afterlife.

>Don't tell Poe
>REEEEEEE LITERALLY NO ONE KNEW WHAT WAS HAPPENING HOLDO WAS LITERALLY FUELING THE TRANSPORTS AND PILOTING THEM HERSELF REEEE

Poe and his friends were the only people ostensibly out of the loop. The mutiny was five people.

>and the Rebels disobey authority in order to do the right thing.
Really? I don't recall that ever really being a theme. The orders Cassian was under was to murder a noncombatant who was trying to defect, Poe was to sit around and not be an asshole for five minutes and if he had done that everyone would have lived.

>Poe was 100% in the right and Holdo is a dumb bitch who deserved her death.
ok incel

No it's a question retard, is this a yes? I'm assuming so

>>proceeds to bet her entire plan on a "one in a million move"(Thanks Rise of Skywalker)
That was never part of her plan you fucking imbecile. That was an improvised desperate move after it all wild south.

The leaders did know. Poe was not a leader of anything. In fact his last action was to get demoted.

You're the one who can't actually provide a response or refutation : ^ )

It's not even a complicated film. Why are basic details of it so difficult for haters to grasp?

>The only reason her plan failed is because Poe leaked it to the enemy

Snoke was able to use the force to sense them fleeing, and Leia should have known Snoke was capable of this. So even if the plan wasn't leaked, and even if no one in the FO decided to look out the window and saw escape ships, they would have been found out.

Because they have absolutely no interest in even attempting to understand anything in the movie and would rather feed their victim complex

>Poe was to sit around and not be an asshole for five minutes and if he had done that everyone would have lived

You mean after Poe saved the entire fleet and the movie itself from the fleet killer even against orders a few minutes prior? Nice try dumbass. You need to try harder

Attached: 1578062530671.jpg (244x206, 7.59K)

Don't you know, the action hero is always entitled to know everything in a military hierarchy because he's got a gun and does stunts dammit.

No im the one asking if you're a fucking retard, how low is your IQ?

Please dont samefag so hard

Poe who was demoted for disobeying orders, yes. Or should they invite the privates and perhaps the janitor up for the military council meetings too?

>Snoke was able to use the force to sense them fleeing
It's never stated in the film that he could sense them through the Force, they just didn't bother having a scene where Snoke is informed of the transports fleeing because it's not that important

>replying to yourself
Proper cope from getting btfo

When you're resorting to this and conspicuously avoiding replying to anything said, you should just close the tab.

>poe was denoted for saving the entire fleet
So youre proving my point. Didn't I tell to try harder retard?

Your point being...what? His ranking officer demoted him. Are you disputing that this happened?

Yup thats a cope, dont be so obvious next time newfriend

He was demoted because he got dozens of people killed and got the entire bombing fleet destroyed for a hollow victory

>b-b-but the dreadnought would have destroyed the fleet during the chase!!!
Pure conjecture, citation needed, Star Wars is not real and it is not scientific fact that we know the range or firepower of the guns

never mind that they had exactly zero knowledge of the hyperspace tracking

Its established as a fleet killer. They make it clear for the audience. Suddenly experienced war pilot poe doesn't know what he is talking about for the sake of your argument? Lol thats not how it works. The film calls it a fleet killer, if you claim it isnt you have to prove retard