At the end of End Game they made a big deal about replacing all the stones exactly as they were. But they dusted the chitari and Gamara stayed on earth. So how are they going to put those elements back 'exactly as they were'?
i don't see how the chitari being dusted and gamora staying prevents them from doing that
Jordan Fisher
It fucks up the timeline with them not being returned. If they weren't returned then there was no attack on New York. No Gamora meeting Quill, nothing.
Eli Green
those chitari were from 2014 so in the attack in new york already happened. The movie establishes that changing the past doesn't change the future, because when you travel back in time you're not going backwards in your own timeline but actually travelling to a different one, an alternate universe. So Gamora not meeting the original Quill in the universe that 2014 Thanos came from doesn't matter. Pay attention to the movie
Asher Jackson
What? You're confused friend. The chitari are the same ones from the battle of New York. Also in the movie they explicitly say that you need to return the stones or fuck up the future.
Daniel Clark
In that timeline. Fucking tilda Swinton literally explained this to the hulk while she talked about returning the stones. They need it for THEIR timeline not the hulks.
Jason Flores
No. The chemo magician explicitly says that taking the stones will help hulks reality, creating a new timeline separate from the one that hadn't been altered, but leave hers defenceless with no time stone.
How do people fail to understand kids movies so badly.
Gabriel Allen
time travel is retarded yes, now post more green Zoe
Taking the stones long term fucks up the bald one's timeline because her universe won't have the stones. The agreement is basically borrow the stones and return them timeline wise the instant they were taken. It's not causality shenanigans, it's just their literal absence. While the stones got atomised and can't be harnessed, they still exist in the original timeline. Eldritch bullshit starts happening if the stones stop existing in your timeline
Tyler Adams
Not only does Tilda Swissarmyknife explain this point, Paul Rudd and Tony Stark explain it too. Over and over and over again.
They do a terrible job of explaining it but its possible that its not real time travel. Its just dimensional travel where you travel to a dimension that is identical except at a different time.
So they are fixing their universe by taking things and fucking others.
Jaxson Parker
STOP!!!!!! IM A PERSON!!!!!!!!!
Nicholas Wood
I will never not find this form of time travel logic retarded. Seriously, why not just take the regular time travel mechanics and use them? Was it all for that one line that went like "lol, it's not THAT kind of time travel, silly"? There is no reason not to use the regular time travel logic because then, Cap coming back would have been perfectly plausible and all the other shit wouldn't have been so unecessarily complicated
James Young
Guess they couldn’t be bothered with the butterfly effect
Jacob Flores
Yeah, but there is no reason not to. The movie would have actually been improved if they had done that
Hunter Cook
HOLD THA PHONE...
So Iron Man snapped his fingers and dusted Thanos and his army - would that not include Gamora and Nebula? Are you telling me, somehow in all that mass dusting... Gamora didn't die?
I'm kinda okay with that, cause I thought GOTG 3 was gonna be all about rescuing Gamora from the afterlife.
Brandon Williams
>The chitari are the same ones from the battle of New York
That thanos and his forces were from 2014 right before gotg 1 meaning after the battle of new york you worthless fucking retard. Imagine struggling with capeshit. Sage
Jack Howard
They changed the timelines retard, they just need to make sure the stones are ‘present’ in the universe at all times by returning them the exact moment they left.
Imagine being so brain dead that endgame confused you
Brayden Anderson
Why would it include their nebula you retard? And gamora wasnt their enemy and helping on the battlefield for quite some time (all woman scene and shit). He could have easily saw her at some point and knew she was a friendly. Or could have mentally thought "snap away all our enemies here". Who gives a shit dumbass
Jackson Perez
dont think about it its not even worth it
Josiah Baker
>Op btfo I can only hope these fags can stay in their containment board