Here's your Liet Kynes bro, hope you like you male character turned into black women ;)

> (You)
>It's a case-by-case basis. Let's apply your logic to the character in question - Liet Kynes. What are some characteristics of Liet Kynes that are inherently tied to that characters gender and race? Why can't the character be a black female in this particular case?

Because sex and ethnicity is part of the character's identity. There is no need to change them unless you imply that there is shortage of white actors in a 200 million production. Let's be real here: they change their ethnicity and sex because they don't want a full cast of white actors. It has nothing to do with adapting the source material.

Lets play the other side. Say that they were adapting a book where of one the main characters is a black woman. They get a white man for the part. There would be outrage in the media even though its exactly the same thing. And you would furious too because you are a hypocrite and dishonest.

>the author was too scared to portray the Turks as what they were, PoC.
At least there is a vague reference to the Star and Crescent.

Do black people even appreciate sci-fi? They keep throwing them as if they're big consumers of the genre.

>And you would furious too because you are a hypocrite and dishonest.
Not really. I'm all for subversion in art. I think it can be a great way to introduce a new perspective to the character.

These changes are aimed at self-hating whites.

Dune? more like Nig

see this is a prime example how they whipped people into submission

Thanks. Do please elaborate.

okay fine but do you have to shitpost dune threads for a year

everyone outside of America is fine not having a race conversation every day

>Can a black actor behave like a white guy? Sure, but he will never be as good as a white actor.
Literally what the fuck does this even mean dude. Are you implying that all black people act one way and all white people act in some distinct other way and there's just no possible way for these behaviors to have overlap

other people outside america have less than 10 - 20 percent of their population being niggers

i don't care, i just hate the American's obsession with race

it's all you fuckers ever talk about, on Yas Forums, on Yas Forums, on /his/, on any board it's just race, race, race

get new material for christ's sake

it will happen to you too, eventually

>im supposed to believe this bitch united the fremen and made them believe in terraforming

bro come on

I don't get it, both aren't real?

you hope

>eventually you will also be completely fucking incapable of having a coherent discussion about the intended topic of an online forum

oh jesus christ please no

Superficial changing of characters via race/gender doesn't inherently offer "new perspective".

You could have the exact source character in appearance and change their stances via writing and it would offer a new perspective.

Again: changing the superficial doesn't inherently offer anything new.

How is paul meant to admire a fatherfigure who is a black women?

it's already happening, don't be so mad about it

>Can an actor act? Sure, but he'll never be as good as the real thing.
Insightful. Bravo, Yas Forums. You exposed acting as a kind of make believe.

Attached: 1538800677040.png (916x1067, 1.36M)

armenian genocide never happened

oh shit its a nigger

>american trying ot bait me into a conversation about race

EAT SHIT AND DIE AMERIFAT

U mad tranny?

don't be so mad about it

Says the faggot who never read Dune.

Dune? more like Coon.

>u mad

Oh well.

Like jewish

So is it a fundamental change to a character's essence or a superficial change? You can't have it both ways.

yea u mad

Who cares, Liet dies in the most retarded way like 30 minutes into the movie.

>u mad

Oh, well.

Blacks are a biological weapon employed by rich vampire people as part of a cynical scheme to make money; søypeople defending it are half useful idiots, half aspirants to join the coven themselves

u so mad it's funny

>American conversation

bruh just range ban the whole country

Paul never gave a fuck about Liet, his father figure is Leto Atreides who happens to be his FATHER.
He looks up to Siltgar, Gurney and his other teachers, never to Liet

Black dude here, a lot of us do like scifi. Though honestly, not enough of us do, it's probably the most big-brain of the genre fiction.

This.

exactly