Marvel’s She-Hulk Writer Dana Schwartz: “Fan Gatekeeping Is A Profoundly Toxic Subculture”

who was in the wrong here?

>Marvel Studios upcoming Disney Plus She-Hulk TV series writer Dana Schwartz recently declared that “fan gatekeeping is a profoundly toxic subculture.”

>These comments come after Schwartz railed on South Park back in February saying, “It seems impossible to overstate the cultural damage done by South Park.”

>In response to the ensuing criticism and outright mockery of her statements regarding South Park, Schwartz would play the victim and ask, “Is there something that women are ALLOWED to have an opinion on?”

>Schwartz’s decided to publicly shame one of her critics as well as the entire male gender. She stated, “Men really need to take a deep breath.”

>Juicyrevival asked, “So where on your Instagram is there a mention that you’re passionate about comics? In a medium where frauds are spotted like criminals casing a banks- how do you truly believe you’ll write something interesting?”

>Juicyrevivial added, “It’s a connected medium with a character driven by its original source material. My question is this, why are you interested beyond the money? What makes you want to write about She-Hulk when you clearly are not interested in that genre?

>Schwartz asked, “Earnest question: do male writers deal with this? (Also imagine seriously believing anyone got into comics for the money lol)

>Schwartz then wrote on Twitter, “The idea that I need to somehow prove my “worthiness” in order to work in a certain genre is incredibly toxic (and also v v sexist).”

>Schwartz then claims, “Fan gatekeeping is a profoundly toxic subculture, the people who think enjoying a thing gives them ownership over it.”

boundingintocomics.com/2020/03/30/marvels-she-hulk-writer-dana-schwartz-fan-gatekeeping-is-a-profoundly-toxic-subculture/

Attached: 2020.03.30-03.37-boundingintocomics-5e82121d32bbc.png (750x400, 174.29K)

I don't care and neither should you faggot.

Who gives a shit about any of this?

This nonsense has been going on for what, a decade now? Am I supposed to still be mad about it?

>""Schwartz""

she looks like a cunt desu

>Also imagine seriously believing anyone got into comics for the money lol
lol right?

Attached: mcu.jpg (1000x563, 330.41K)

Jew women are the kikes of gender.

Comics are dead because fans didn't gatekeep well enough. Everything that comes out is sjw trash that no one reads.

>white woman creates drama to attract attention and make people feel bad for her
Sounds like any other day

Who cares? Were any of you really going to watch a fucking She Hulk show?

gatekeeping is just quality control honestly

lol show hasn't even dropped yet and she's already attacking fans. I'm sure this will work out well.

Depends on who gets cast.

>do male writers deal with this?
Have women ever created anything worth gatekeeping?

If it was true to the comics where a big-titted green woman dresses in bikini spandex and solves court cases while fucking everything that moves?

Yeah, I'd have given it a season or two to find its legs.

So many years and fools still dont know where they are. See you in the generals retard

Attached: 1570784683167.png (355x444, 220.23K)

>people who think enjoying a thing gives them ownership over it.
It does though. When you feel that you've lost the ownership, you don't enjoy it any more.

Don't just roll over.

Proper She-Hulk is based.

>>Schwartz asked, “Earnest question: do male writers deal with this? (Also imagine seriously believing anyone got into comics for the money lol)
Yes? Fans call male comic book writers hacks all the fucking time, and debate which one is canon and which one is guilty of character assassination. I barely read any comics and even I can tell you this. Fuck, you could probably go over to Yas Forums right this minute and see retarded examples of this shit.

How does someone in the comic industry genuinely not know this?

...

How long before this gets old and no one cares anymore? This PR bullshit is so old. A Jewish woman whining about a primarily men's entertainment genre she's pushed herself into not because she enjoys it, but so she can bring feminism to it, and how she's not instantly successful when she shits on the entire fandom, gender and everyone on the right of Stalin political spectrum. And comics, aren't the comics consistently failing because of this garbage?

Strange game... The only way to win is not to play. Whenever that fat fag from the quartering pops up on my YouTube bitching about this shit I get annoyed. People like that are also shilling on this stupid nonsense, just at a different level of the food chain.

who gives a single fuck about some random oven-dodger?

I fucking hate Yas Forums, so I genuinely want to defend this, but I can't. This is going to be yet another humorless, "WOMEN FUCK YEAH," thing where anything even remotely funny is deemed """offensive""" isn't it? Christ, She-Hulk is a character who's SUPPOSED to be humorous, jesus.

Not to mention the only people who bitch and complain about gatekeeping are exactly the sorts who the gate is meant to keep out. I've never met anyone who complained about it who was actually well-versed in what they were talking about.

Attached: 1585538219507.jpg (800x2101, 101.74K)

>“Is there something that women are ALLOWED to have an opinion on?”
Which makeup tutorials are good?

Comics are dead anyway. It literally doesn't matter what happens to the characters from here on out.

Gatekeeping is good though.

>(Also imagine seriously believing anyone got into comics for the money lol)
When Disney built a multibillion dollar franchise off of them after decades of being laughed at as "nerd shit" and being butchered on screen, yes, you should be able to question the motives of someone trying to get in now that it's "hot"

Attached: shrug.png (167x303, 6.69K)

This is why Marvel is hiring these women to parade the corpse about for woke points. Because it literally doesn't matter.

I would if it wasn't on one of the 24 competing streaming platforms that I'm not buying into. Dan Slott's 2004 run of She-hulk was cool. It was Ally McBeal but with superhero law shenanigans and muscle girl fetish fuel. Great fun. I'd love to see it done right on screen.

nobody fucking cares about any of this except retards (inb4 offended by the word retard) also gatekeeping doesnt exist there are billions of people on the planet and everyone with their own opinion stop being a liberal snowflake fucking faggot

>Dan Slott

This nigga sucked ass on Spider-Man, but he wrote a genuinely compelling and fun Hank Pym on Mighty Avengers. I always feel conflicted when he's brought up.

Inb4 Disney fires her so literally anyone will bother watching this piece of shit

The whole concept of "toxicity" is just women failing to understand male social practices.

>Schwartz asked, “Earnest question: do male writers deal with this?
See JJ Abrams Jr getting into writing along with easily a dozen other male writers who are suddenly all about writing comics out of no where. It happens regardless because fans want good writing, not someone cashing in for a paycheck and their own politics/slant ideas of how to change a character into something else

She Hulk is absurdist comedy along the lines of the Tick, so yea and if it was like the comics you would too.

If I wanted to gatekeep She Hulk, I'd buy everything in the .10 bin at my friendly local.

isn't this the same lady that was bitching about South Park's 'immense cultural damage'?

Of course it exists, and it's a good thing. People keep each other in check, otherwise standards drop. This is like basic foundations of civilization stuff.

>Comics are dead because fans didn't gatekeep well enough. Everything that comes out is sjw trash that no one reads.
This can't be said enough. Comics got fucked over HARD from social justice and will probably never recover.

>The idea that I need to somehow prove my “worthiness” in order to work in a certain genre is incredibly toxic

Leftist seething that you actually have to know about the specialization you were put in via affirmative action would be funny if it wouldn't ruin everything they touch.

Attached: Screenshot_20200207-210421_Brave.jpg (1080x4259, 1.5M)

>Schwartz

not even, it's just women being schizos.

>post opinion on a public forum
>people dissect said opinion and respond
>literally have a fucking delusion and imagine that men are forbidding you from having an opinion

>someone asks why you are doing the job you are doing
>someone asks what makes you good at your job
>have a delusion that these are questions that men don't get asked despite being common interview questions
>say that fans think they own a comic because someone asked why you want to be a comic writer

this is literally mental illness. a failure to perceive reality and respond appropriately, not just a difference between the sexes.

The fuck did South Park do? Didn’t they just have an episode about a bunch of girls BTFO Cartman because they were all better D&D players than him and half of his board game club?

But comicbook movies have never made more money than recently, blasting comic book sales out of any semblance of relevancy.... lets face it, your little nerd hobby has been taken over and it was super profitable.

Hope it drops like her career.

>Writing a TV shows is EXACTLY THE SAME as being a firefighter!!!!!!!!!!!

>says retarded shit about a show she literally doesn't watch and isn't smart enough to get (despite 99% of it being obvious metaphors and fart jokes)
>doubles down and claims the only reason people are calling her a retard is because she's a woman (which is honestly a stealth insult to all the talented and successful female creators out there)
>assumes capeshit doesn't make money after Endgame was literally the most profitable movie of all human history and anyone who touches a Marvel movie is immediately elevated to being a household name
>assumes male comic creators don't get shit on by fans
>after flaunting her ignorance, tries to assume a position of authority and explain to a community how their community works
>literally her only defense is "that's toxic and sexist", two buzzwords that have all but lost meaning
>all of her promotion of this show has been centered around her attacking other shows and calling potential viewers CHUDs
What a fucking idiot, this is gonna be dreck. Shame, Shulkie is a fun character who would be well suited to a lighthearted action/rom-com show.

Superior Spidey was based though, and if not for it, we wouldn't have gotten the magnificent Superior Foes of Spider-Man.

Kikes like schwartz are literally gatekeepers when they push an original fandom out and say that anybody who is "racist" or "sexist" (aka white men who don't hate themselves) isn't welcome.

Attached: 1499132375545.jpg (4040x626, 451.42K)

That's the thing though. Women aren't really socialised to expect to hear people's honest opinions or actually receive criticism.

Look at the fucking beak on that heeb!

She took their recurring message of "its gay and stupid to care about meaningless nonsense, there are actual issues in the world" as an insult because the only issues she and people like her care about are all meaningless nonsense

It's just one example of absolutely commonplace leftist practice.

Attached: 1580710023057.jpg (750x810, 41.77K)

oh boy wait until you guys see her latest tweet

Based

Writers don't make shit bro. Maybe 1% do but those are household names.

It's idpol, not leftist you fucking dumbo.

Superheroes/=comics
Comics aren't selling, and if they intend to actually keep publishing them they should probably pander a little to people who actually buy them.

>standards only matter if lives are on the line
People just like things that aren't shit, okay?

>who was in the wrong here?
>(((Schwartz)))
Guess who, Sherlock

It would be funny if people weren't dying as a result

Attached: 1502346709456.png (1507x2883, 608.67K)

This. So much this.

Shit like this makes me so angry. Because in certain fields, diversity absolutely matters. It's GOOD to have a diverse set of opinions, outlooks, and skills in the room when you're looking to provide a service or solve a problem. If you're running a school where 50% of the student body is poor black kids from the inner city but 100% of teachers are rich white adults from the suburbs, you're going to run into problems. If you're looking to create content meant to be enjoyed by a primarily male audience, but all of the voices in your writers room are female, there's a chance you'll miss the mark. Diversity in the work place makes sense because it gives you more skills and ideas to work with and achieve the best results.

But these fucking lunatics only ever frame it as "you need designated race ambassadors, brown people are ALWAYS dumber and poorer than us whites so we need to give them a leg up", and then they act surprised when no one goes for it. I seriously don't get it. Progressivism has morphed into a genuine mental sickness, a dogma devoid of any sense of self-awareness or reality.

>tfw you don't care about comics but just want to see more Yas Forums women superheroes for the inevitable r34 influx

Attached: b19.jpg (736x678, 60.02K)

>NotRealLeftshittism(tm)

Getting really fucking tired of your shit.

Attached: 41utwyYFx5L._SX258_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg (260x297, 14.44K)

>It's GOOD to have a diverse set of opinions, outlooks, and skills in the room when you're looking to provide a service or solve a problem
Except that's not what they mean by "diversity" and having a vagina or dark skin doesn't mean you're going to have a different view that will help solve a problem

Attached: 1465369502116.jpg (1309x515, 212.76K)

>inb4 She-Hulk isnt muscular because that would promote an impossible standard of beauty
>inb4 she doesn't explode out of her clothes and merely wears a one-size fits all burka in order to avoid offending anyone with her body