what do they eat
What do they eat
Nathaniel Myers
Other urls found in this thread:
en.wikipedia.org
twitter.com
Blake Rodriguez
What do they eat?
Jayden James
/thread
Christian Gonzalez
Cherry tomatos
Ian Baker
Orc
Oliver Morgan
Pelennor FIELDS dipshit
Carter Taylor
Their legs. They don't need those.
Ryder Ross
Fish obviously.
Nicholas Powell
onions
John Sanchez
food
Samuel Rogers
What did they do with the hundred thousand dead orcs and giant oliphants on their front step?
Daniel White
OP fucking wrecked
Henry Reed
convert them into pet food?
Eli Nguyen
why is Gondor so shitty in the movies?
it's basically reduced to Minas Tirith and the dry desert around it, its soldiers suck and kill like 3 total orcs, etc.
Carter Richardson
Urban areas are surrounded by farmland that is brought in with modern transportation and refrigeration.
Return of the King was the worst film in the trilogy and the big battle was a boring cgi-fest that had none of the atmosphere of Helms Deep.
Thomas Rivera
Coom
Brandon Moore
there's ports and airports and roads coming from all over
there is NOTHING outside of Minas Thirit, anything outside those walls is COMPROMISED due to proximity to orcs so you can't have a high amount of trade coming in
Noah Miller
reminder that tolkien as always thought of this stuff
Aaron Thomas
in any castle you'd have the rich people inside and then outside there'd be vast settlements of lower class people who do the actual work to supply and maintain the city (just like in modern cities), there is nothing like this here and it makes no sense.
The capital of gondor has room for like 200 people, there should be thousands living outside the walls
Grayson Collins
This is one of the issues that I take with fantasy movies. Massive cities placed in isolated locations, with nothing nearby.
In real life, medieval cities were generally surrounded by farmland, and often right on rivers (Minas Tirith was thankfully close to the river but still strangely there was nothing but grass between them.)
Matthew Morales
burned them in the furnaces hundreds a day
Jason Lewis
read the books. literally explains exactly what you said.
movie ditched it.
Wyatt Gray
And yet it had the best scene of the entire cinema, the rohirrim charge
I dare any of you to name a better scene.
Jaxson Cook
Idris Elba
Isaiah Lewis
>in any castle you'd have the rich people inside and then outside there'd be vast settlements of lower class people
Wrong, there's loads of castles that are just strategic fortifications without a city attached
Leo Taylor
>Elminster riding from The Friendly Arms Inn to Candlekeep
Jose Ross
MAGGOTY BREAD, FOR THREE STINKING QUARANTINES
Jacob Sullivan
they have an arrangement with minas morgul. once in a blue moon orcfrens raid osgiliath and catapult the heads of gondorian soldiers over the walls.
Connor Martin
>Return of the King was the worst film in the trilogy and the big battle was a boring cgi-fest that had none of the atmosphere of Helms Deep.
This. And people don't get why Tolkiens son hated the movies.
Dylan Adams
Orc and Uruk dairy.
Why else do you think we never see orc females?
Elijah Wood
Hackson.
Justin Cruz
Even supplying the citizens with water every day, from the river a few miles away, would have been a massive headache.
Camden Sullivan
This.
>what do they eat?
Kayden Baker
It’s called aquifers and springs
Sebastian Anderson
Woah bros thats kinda based
Easton Sanchez
Underrated post
Jeremiah Brooks
Yeah, I’ve only ever seen the movies but I wondered why Denethor couldn’t pull levies together but Theoden could “muster the rohirrim”
Joseph Rivera
fpbp
OP a fucking moron
Ryan Adams
Better question is: WHY do they eat?
Ever thought about that, huh?
Hudson Price
Top kek
Michael Green
Wait a minute...
Robert Nguyen
What do they eat?
Easton Murphy
Feed and Seed
Asher Cruz
>Wrong, there's loads of castles that are just strategic fortifications without a city attached
where did he say there are "cities" attached to every castle, you dumb FAGGOT? he said there are vast settlements of lower caste people outside, ie: typically farming communities and small hamlets.
en.wikipedia.org
>The Pelennor, also referred to as the Pelennor Fields, was the district that virtually surrounded Minas Tirith, and formed the city's "townlands": a fertile area of intensive agriculture. It was about 12 miles across, and fairly flat, although there were some hillocks. On its west stood the massive bulwark of Mount Mindolluin, and on its east ran the great river Anduin; "many rills" ran across the Pelennor from the highlands to the river. Minas Tirith stood inside its south-west corner.
Luis Morgan
>vast settlements of lower caste people outside
That's what is called a city
see
Lucas Mitchell
Yeah this was a bit too much.
Caleb Morris
Hope
Henry Rivera
Why does Tolkien's son matter? Did he inherit some LOTR genes making his opinion on his dads books equal to his fathers?
Evan Turner
>puilaurens
this is within half a mile of the castle, if you zoom out there are multiple, even larger flat, farmlands within 2-3 miles.
>>vast settlements of lower caste people outside
>That's what is called a city
nope, the definition of a city is:
A city is a large human settlement. It can be defined as a permanent and densely settled place with administratively defined boundaries whose members work primarily on non-agricultural tasks.
a city is ONE settlement, the other poster said settlements as in PLURAL as in multiple, as in spread out, not part of the castle/main city's community.
Owen Perez
what do they eat?
Charles Martinez
they probably went up into the mountains to hunt. Meat was on the menu.
Carter Clark
Camden Ross
Adam Jenkins
What do they eat?
Connor Clark
>we could have had sauron fighting instead of another cgi orc
Daniel Scott
Carson Green
test
Jordan Ward
I mean the guy pretty autistically dedicated his life to his dad's works. If anyone has a insight into the story it would be him.
Ryan Gomez
Fellowship is full of better scenes
>let me risk a little more light
>boromirs death
>anything with the Balrog
God I love the first movie so fucking much. So much better than the rest.
James Brown
those are fortresses, just for armies
Alexander Long
damn south german castles are so fuckin comffy
Cameron Morgan
Helm's Deep was a directorial shitfest but plainly superior to Pelennor.
>tfw the Swan Knights' charge and the absolute carnage of the sally from Minas Tirith got replaced with indistinct green shit
Austin Jackson
What a cringe idea, I think Viggo convinced Jackson not to do it
Kevin King
lime
Blake Bailey
Minas Tirith gets a shitload of trade from the coast, from Rohan and food from Ithilien
Daniel Cox
their neighbors