Ruins lightsaber one scene into trilogy highly dependent on it

because theretofore it was a mythic blade, unmaterial, that simply passed through whatever substance it encountered. Making it just a really hot plasma is bathos.
It's the same thing as what people felt (whether they misunderstood the scene or not) it sounded to the audience as if the force was reduced from the supernatural 'way of all things' to which you could become attuned, to a material force, parallel to magnetism, interacted with by particular molecules in cells with suitable organs, the way only particles with electric charge feel electric force.
transcendence descended to physics lucas should have worn a fedora for these

but is absolutely right, you can't have bare skin that fucking close to molten metal & not get severe burns.
And no "shield droid allowing the ebin lightsaber lava fight" cop out here, wither.

didnt read lol

everyone knows it's just a laser sword dude. it's not excalibur.

you don't get burned putting your hand next to a laser beam. even if that's not strictly what they are or how they operate, it's obviously a guiding principle and example since they are called literally laser swords by the creator. If you use a laser to heat metal though you will get radiataive heating of your nearby hand, however so they guy is right even though it's not the point of the thread

You used all those words without actually saying shit.

He used the force to keep his hands cool.

i use the force to keep your sister's pussy hot

it shouldn't get bogged in the door it makes it look like a gay little blowtorch

>being this autistic
hard and soft sci-fi fags will never learn

so in other words, you can't.

Attached: russian lava magic.webm (1280x720, 2.86M)

>what are you talking about? is this some new trolling?
It's a joke. OP meant that lucas ruined the concept of the lightsaber but user proposed a literal interpretation where the individual lightsaber in the scene is mechanically "ruined" due to abuse

It’s fantasy lmao

STAH WAR u wot i was farkin IN'AT you know

Attached: _88672173_getty_ridley.jpg (976x549, 47.55K)

>unmaterial, that simply passed through whatever substance it encountered
Holy shit how can you be so wrong off the bat.
It's a laser sword, it's always been a laser sword. For the many many years of books and comics before TPM came out, it was always a hot laser sword.

changing it from soft to attempted hard is the thing i'm complaining about

It doesn't bother me, really. It's just dumb. He could have done the same thing but not put his hand six inches from the molten metal.

the words 'it's a laser sword' is not getting across anything to me so perhaps you could rephrase your claim

>mili seconds of exposure is the same as over a minute

She looks distinctly Welsh.

>He could have done the same thing but not put his hand six inches from the molten metal
It's implied by it not even sticking out of the other side of the door(s) that they're nearly as thick as the blade is long.

no that's the PCOS

>miliseconds

More like tenths of a second, but I see your point. Should also be noted that he is physically touching it, not merely flash-welding it.

I have no words for this other than to question exactly what metal that is. Some has a far lower melting point than others.

Laser sword my dude.
Laser
Sword

Attached: 1542729822784.jpg (500x500, 28.42K)

Probably iron.

I think that's lead.

like people saying it was never that mystical as a weapon, ok why can't a jedi just get a bit of steel pipe and use that to deflect blaster bolts

>2,800°F
Impossible really, fucker shouldn't have a hand.
>621.5°F
Much more believable.

>lead
Molten lead looks nothing like that. Iron glows the same bright yellow/orange as in the video.

It's called the leidenfrost effect

that might make sense given the respirator. still

iron glows bright white, it's fucking 2000 degrees. all that shit you see in the movies is fake shit.

Phantom Menace is so underrated. It’s absolute kino from start to finish. Even Jar Jar is charming all these years later. The world gets worse through the years but TPM just gets better and better.

>Molten lead looks nothing like that
There's a fuck ton of "_____ STICKS THEIR BARE HAND IN MOLTEN LEAD" videos, but haven't found on yet I can see glowing. But there's not one in anything like the metal is in that other video though.
youtube.com/watch?v=QJIBYPGXC8Q

This guy's skin is probably like leather, a bunch of keyboard warriors have no idea. My father had very rough hands and he wasn't a hard laborer by any means. All the same looks pretty scary.

he had to have his hand amputated because of this, I hope a 30 second meme video was worth it

there is a cut in the video right before he does it. where he maybe .. wets his hands i dunno

>the shit you see in the movies

You mean google images?

Proof?

src

citation?

His hand were wet for sure, if not from water than from the amount of sweat he would build up working in a metal forge in a full covered outfit.

Do you have a source on that?

Source?

A source. I need a source.

Sorry, I mean I need a source that explicitly states your argument. This is just tangential to the discussion.

No, you can't make inferences and observations from the sources you've gathered. Any additional comments from you MUST be a subset of the information from the sources you've gathered.

You can't make normative statements from empirical evidence.

Do you have a degree in that field?

A college degree? In that field?

Then your arguments are invalid.

>iron glows bright white

Oh, you mean like in the webm he just posted? That's a very tiny stream.

It's better now than I remembered it to be in '99. The disappointment then was huge. But it's still not all that "great". The child acting from both Lloyd & Portman is atrociously bad, and that & Jar Jar seem to accentuate all the worst parts of one another.

based

Fucking brainlets saying his hand should have been burnt by the door. Nigger was a Jedi Master, repelling, redirecting or even absorbing the heat is all pretty simple with the force.

>You can't make normative statements from empirical evidence.

If he did that, he would have a source, you dipshit.

calm down autismo

>jedis so smrt and stronk
>all jedis were killed by some shit they didn't see coming
lol

Was waiting to see if anyone was going to make this argument. It's true tho.

>replying to clear & obvious pasta

i think if it was iron the video would be overexposed and it would look like night time. indeed it would be quite a bit brighter. it's difficult to film molten metals with digital, it's like filming a lightbulb.

You can do the same thing for a lot of extreme heats. If you move quick enough, it only evaporates the moisture on your hands.

Reverse works for dry ice. You can hold it and even put it in your mouth, you just need to keep moving it so it doesn't have time to suck the heat out of the source.

lol jedi rocks more like jedis rekt

the prequels were good
dont bother replying as i will leave this thread, i just wanted you manchildren babies to know that the OT was no fucking masterpiece either

he fist fucks ur mom and his hand becomes impervious to hell fire kek

The prequels were the best trilogy. Fight me.

Only other thing I can think off that has a similar look would be aluminum. It also keeps its molten color for a while too, based on the splatters surrounding the pit it's being dumped into so it can't be under 800 degrees F.

the first movie is objectively shit, terrible on many fronts, remembered only for teenage nat portman, jedi taken and duel of the fates. the games are actually better.

second movie is also very bad, basically a video game, only the third movie is remotely good, and then only just.

ban this clearly underage faggot

quads have spoken
>only JUST

>he fist fucks ur mom and his hand becomes impervious to hell fire kek
rekt

The second is actually worse than the first one.
The botched love story with shit dialogue delivered cringeworthily is more unwatchable than any of JJ's antics.