Thoughts?

Joel is in his 50 though

>"Fans want..."
Who are these unnamed fans? Is it all fans or some fans?

I support Hugh Jackman in anything.

There's only a handful GoT actors I want to see again and Maisie is sure as fuck not one of them. Sorry.

Jackman would be based

>he already played the gruff hardass dad character
Good. Is that supposed to be a negative?

fans want a lot of stupid things, but there's a reason they're fans and not the ones making shit.

>maisie doing an American accent
No

They're probably gonna choose some guy that's 50+ and some woman that's like 25-30 years old to play a girl that was 14 at the time... It's gonna be shit

yes for hugh, no for maisie

Fan castings are cringe 99% of the time. People always picks that are too big for these kind of things. To actually get good performances, lower level actors are needed