Is Dave Filoni a hack Yas Forums?

Is Dave Filoni a hack Yas Forums?

Attached: FB1B8284-A699-4DD2-9C1C-4849C6C8743B.jpg (1013x744, 144.45K)

In theory it's not a bad idea, but the way they went about it in the Sequel Trilogy only ended up wrecking both Luke and Leia.

God Himself cucked Disney out of doing this by killing Carrie Fisher. What does THAT tell you?

>rebels
>resistance
>nu-clone wars
Yeah he's a fucking idiot. That quote only adds to his misery

It may be time to consider the possibility that Lucas' involvement with Clone Wars benefited it more than we thought at the time.

He's not a great writer just one of the best of a bunch of very bad writers.

Would have been a nice idea if they had gone with that from the beginning, as it was, they shifted to it in the last fucking movie, and it had no real impact, especially given all the mentorship scenes were leftover footage of a dead woman, with the other actor trying to play a game of Mad Libs with existing nonsense dialogue.

He's actually a genius. Anyone who disagrees is a salty faggot.

That.

we already fucking knew that, the show had a huge spike in quality once Lucas got more involved around Season 3

Lucas' problem was never ideas, it was execution.

would have been nice in general if they had had a FUCKING PLAN from the beginning. Then Rian wouldn't have fucked everything up and forced Abrams and the producers to attempt a massive pivot in the final act.

He didn't fuck everything up. 7 & 8 were filmed practically back to back, way before retarded Snoke theories and other shit got going. He looked at the nostalgia wank of JJ's film and thought maybe he could make the thematic arc be about breaking cycles. Kill off the retarded replacement emperor and let the new protagonist actually be her own person. Made a story about how passing the torch is a noble act of trust, not a concession of failure.

Rian left JJ with a blank fucking slate, where all the characters were ready to go on a new journey with new challenges. But no, you all shit your britches because the Asian girl wasn't hot enough and rode a boring horse, and the precious legacy lightsaber was broken.

>UUUUH! Why wahmen stronk without Skywalker cum!
>Why no reference to sooper awsum Plaggis!
>Green titty milk UUUUH!

Eat shit.

>Made a story about how passing the torch is a noble act of trust, not a concession of failure.

We clearly didn’t see the same TLJ

>asian girl wasn’t hot enough

Only literal homosexuals say that. But your wrong on everything else

NO ONE GAVE A FUCK ABOUT THE LIGHTSABER BEFORE JJ WENT FULL RETARD AND TRIED TO MAKE EVERYONE CARE ABOUT THEM, like how ruin used the fucking dice.

get outta here Rian

>Blah blah Star Wars blah blah feminism

Sounds like a bitch

Attached: 1584014295922.jpg (1079x1076, 169.55K)

I'd like to believe that he's just trying to excuse what a clusterfuck the sequels became due to a lack of planning, but I wouldn't be surprised at this point if he truly believes this.

everyone who isn't JJ, Kathleen, Rian, or this guy have been doing their own little deflections about how trash the sequels turned out

He tried on multiple occasions to insert his OC from an old Star Wars roleplaying forum into his shows and would have both based the OC off himself and paired him romantically with his female OC that he was able to get into the show and has ruined several plots be either shoehorning her in or refusing to let her exit gracefully. He's also a fucking furry.
So yeah, pretty hackish.

I think he can get results, but I think he can only get them when someone with authority over him and a clear head is forcing him to not use his stupider ideas.

>makes some shit stuff
>gets away with it because his fanboys defend him

at least he hasn't managed to finagle his self-insert in in a meaningful way yet

>some

Yes, yes he is. It's just that he looks good in comparisson to everyone else.

Here's the whole thing.

Attached: 1586652179040.jpg (314x640, 58.12K)

Wheres it from user?

Who do you think Ezra was based on?

Attached: 1579742683931.jpg (1519x651, 167.45K)

>uses time travel as a plot device to save his waifu from dying at the last minute
>genius

This. Being that Rey was female, Leia being her Obi-Wan could've been kino.

Without George to consult (which he tried to do in Rebels but Lucasfilm gave him a fat NO), he cannot really do Star Wars anything to the end. He is doubly unable now, considering his arms are tied as to there his stories must tie into.

Well they killed the hot sister

word is they brought him in to fix High Republic, because their writers had been a disaster.

The TFA that should have been...

> Opens with Luke finding Rey (after we follow her scavenger routine for a bit) and recruiting her to join his Jedi temple, him having heard rumors of a force user on Jakku.
> They return to his temple only to find it destroyed and burning, most of the students massacred. Ben Solo's body is not among the dead.
> Luke contacts Han and tells him to meet him with Leia at Coruscant the capital of the New Republic. We get to see what our heroes created after the original trilogy.
> He breaks the news to them and enlist Han to help him find who did this and find Ben if he is still alive. He privately confides in Han a fear that Ben may have been complicit in the massacre but Han dismisses it.
> The 3 eventually confront a masked silent Kylo Ren whom Luke duels and "defeats" but is horrified as believing he recognizes his fighting style as being that of Bens. Han begins to have doubts.
> During this encounter we see some of it from the POV of Stormtrooper Finn working reluctantly under Kylo.
> Kylo kidnaps Rey after seeing her use the force.
> Finn sees her being tortured by Kylo but she barely manages to turn the tables on him using the force. Finn frees her.
> Luke and Han find their way to a giant Starship factory revealing that the First Order have indeed been creating new weapons in spite of their treaty with the New Republic (leia expected such)
> Finn & Rey manage to send a warning to the New Republic about a First Order attack. Leia manages to get enough ships in defensive positions to result in a brutal but indecisive battle. Much collateral damage is wrought upon the capital city on Coruscant.
> Luke makes his way on to the lead First Order ship and slaughters the deck crew in a sequence similar to R1's Vader moment and has the ship collide with another.
> Han confronts Kylo who reveals himself to be Ben. Ends the same way as the real film.
> Rey duels Kylo to a stand still and the First Order is forced to retreat.

>could've been kino.
the sequel trilogy as a whole could've been great if it wasn't being run by idiots and active saboteurs

It does not matter. Nothing they add will ever retcon the NuTrilogy. They will never admit the movies were a mistake and are "not canon anymore". The higher ups at NuLucasfilm put too much at stake, they cannot afford to admit to such a monumental failure. No new stories, no matter who writes them, will never retcon the new movies.

Avatar did just fine without him...

Attached: Aang.png (338x455, 248.36K)

The only person more of a retard would be

>> Luke makes his way on to the lead First Order ship and slaughters the deck crew in a sequence similar to R1's Vader moment and has the ship collide with another.
congratulations user, you managed to come up with something worse than what we got

The Art of the Rise of Skywalker.

Attached: PURR PURR.jpg (1994x968, 194.32K)

Hence they are running into the past. That and all the actors want nothing to do with Star Wars

>Rey duels Kylo to a stand still and the First Order is forced to retreat
Still using "she is such a natural she is a master with no training" shtick, eh?

This would fix so many things while keeping the basic shell of what we got.
> No Snoke.
> No overpowered AF First Order & Starkiller.
> No hyper Rey feats, I'm fine with her dueling Kylo but nothing like her force swaying the Stormtroopers.
> Allow us to actually see what was built after the original trilogy.
> Would allow Han & Luke to spend much of the film together playing Detective.