It was supposed to simplify the continuity of DC comics, but it only make it more confusing.
But what do you think? Would DC comics be better without it?
Was Crisis on Infinite Earths a mistake
Liam Young
Jason Green
COIE was probably the weirdest way to celebrate company's 50th anniversary. What were they thinking? They try to correct sth not needing any correction.
Levi Cruz
If we ever get that The Brave and The Bold COIE musical, then it will not have been a mistake.
Evan Smith
People who say that COIE saved DC comics never actually read any Pre-Crisis comics.
Sorry for being so butthurt btw, but this comic really pisses me off.
Asher Watson
>maybe
Austin Reed
Well it attracted the best talent comics had to offer and gave DC the best 15 years of its existence. So despite the story and continuity changes enraging canon-obsessed fans it really was a huge benefit for the company.
Cooper Bailey
It only got stupid when writers and editors tried to undo what Crisis changed.
Nathaniel Foster
Maybe I need to show some proof that COIE was a mistake, so here it is:
- Supergirl and Powergirl backstory became overly convoluted
- Alfred became Bruce Wayne's foster parent for no reason
- Hawkman became two different characters (Carter Hall and Katar Hol) with different backstories living on the same Earth
-Whole DC history became insanely compressed to only 10 years
Jace Powell
>gave DC the best 15 years of its existence
I'd argue
Joshua Hernandez
>It only got stupid when writers and editors tried to undo what Crisis changed.
But if it didn't happen, you wouldn't have to undo it.
I am not against rebooting old characters, but you didn't have to destroy the Multiverse to do so